Bogin B, MacVean R B
Am J Phys Anthropol. 1981 Aug;55(4):543-51. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.1330550415.
The effects of socioeconomic differences on the nutritional status of two groups of urban living children are considered via an anthropometric assessment of body composition. The sample consists of 981 Guatemala City children, 7.00 to 13.99 years old. Of high and low socioeconomic status (SES). High SES children have larger median values for triceps skinfold, subscapular skinfold, arm circumference, and estimated mid-arm muscle and fat areas than low SES children. Compared with children of a US reference sample, the high SES children generally have larger values for all variables and the low SES children have smaller values. However, the differences between the low SES children and the children of the other two samples are greater for arm fat area than for arm muscle area. The analysis suggests that low SES Guatemalan children suffer to a greater extent from chronic energy, rather than protein, undernutrition. A similar pattern of energy malnutrition has been observed for rural Guatemalan children. These combined data suggest that estimates of fat reserves of the arm provide a useful indication of nutritional status for Third-World children. Results from rural Costa Rican and Honduran studies have been taken to mean that muscle reserves are better than fat reserves as indicators of nutritional status in developing countries. But, those studies did not estimate cross-sectional muscle and fat areas and only considered the extremes of the population distribution for muscle and fat.
通过对身体成分的人体测量评估,探讨了社会经济差异对两组城市生活儿童营养状况的影响。样本包括981名危地马拉城7.00至13.99岁的儿童,分为高社会经济地位(SES)和低社会经济地位两组。高SES儿童的三头肌皮褶厚度、肩胛下皮褶厚度、上臂围以及估计的上臂肌肉和脂肪面积的中位数均大于低SES儿童。与美国参考样本的儿童相比,高SES儿童的所有变量值通常更大,而低SES儿童的值更小。然而,低SES儿童与其他两个样本儿童之间,上臂脂肪面积的差异大于上臂肌肉面积的差异。分析表明,危地马拉低SES儿童受慢性能量营养不良而非蛋白质营养不良的影响更大。危地马拉农村儿童也观察到类似的能量营养不良模式。这些综合数据表明,上臂脂肪储备的估计为第三世界儿童的营养状况提供了有用的指标。哥斯达黎加农村和洪都拉斯的研究结果表明,在发展中国家,肌肉储备作为营养状况指标比脂肪储备更好。但是,那些研究没有估计横断面肌肉和脂肪面积,只考虑了人群分布中肌肉和脂肪的极端情况。