Roberts A J, Abel R M, Alonso D R, Subramanian V A, Paul J S, Gay W A
J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 1980 Jan;79(1):44-58.
The relative effectivenss of hypothermic potassium (K) cardioplegia in conjunction with either continuous or intermittent aortic cross-clamping was evaluated in 20 mongrel dogs. Isovolumetric left ventricular (LV) contractions and myocardial biopsies were obtained before and after a total of 90 minutes of aortic cross-clamping. The dogs were randomly divided into four groups of five dogs each as follows: Group I, continuous 90 minute cross-clamping and multidose K at 4 degrees C (40 mEq/L); Group II, intermittent cross-clamping consisting of six 15 minute periods of cross-clamping separated by 5 minute reperfusion periods and K cardioplegia at 4 degrees C given at the start of each cross-clamping period; Group III, continuous 90 minute cross-clamping and multidose buffered saline at 4 degrees C; Group IV, intermittent cross-clamping, consisting of six 15 minute periods of cross-clamping separated by 5 minute reperfusion periods and buffered saline at 4 degrees C given at the initiation of each cross-clamp period. Group I dogs had the best myocardial performance, with no difference between control values of peak LV pressure and dP/dtmax and those recordings obtained 60 minutes after release of the aortic cross-clamp. Significant depression of LV function was noted in all other groups. Examination of force-velocity and length-tension relationships confirmed better myocardial performance in Groups I and II (multidose K at 4 degrees C) than in Groups III and IV (buffered saline at 4 degrees C). Groups I and III (continuous cross-clamping) had no de-rease in diastolic LV compliance after cross-clamping, whereas compliance was decreased in both Groups II and IV (intermittent cross-clamping) at higher preloads (p less than 0.05 and p less than 0.025, respectively). The wet weight/dry weight myocardial ratios were lower in Groups I and III (continuous cross-clamping) than in Groups II and IV (intermittent cross-clamping). Although creatine phosphate (CP) concentrations were rapidly restored by reperfusion in all groups, adenosine triphosphate (ATP) and glycogen myocardial stores were better preserved at the end of cross-clamping in Groups I and II (multidose K at 4 degrees C). Although LV diastolic compliance was decreased and myocardial water content was increased in Groups II and IV (intermittent cross-clamping), no differences in the minimal extent of subendocardial hemorrhage, edema, and contraction-band necrosis were observed among any of the groups examined electron microscopically. The present study identifies continuous aortic cross-clamping with multidose K at 4 degrees C as a superior method of myocardial protection.
在20只杂种犬中评估了低温钾(K)心脏停搏液联合持续或间歇性主动脉交叉阻断的相对有效性。在总共90分钟的主动脉交叉阻断前后获取等容左心室(LV)收缩和心肌活检样本。将犬随机分为四组,每组五只,如下:第一组,持续90分钟交叉阻断并在4℃给予多剂量K(40 mEq/L);第二组,间歇性交叉阻断,包括六个15分钟的交叉阻断期,期间间隔5分钟再灌注期,并在每个交叉阻断期开始时给予4℃的K心脏停搏液;第三组,持续90分钟交叉阻断并在4℃给予多剂量缓冲盐水;第四组,间歇性交叉阻断,包括六个15分钟的交叉阻断期,期间间隔5分钟再灌注期,并在每个交叉阻断期开始时给予4℃的缓冲盐水。第一组犬的心肌性能最佳,LV峰值压力和dP/dtmax的对照值与主动脉交叉阻断解除60分钟后获得的记录之间无差异。在所有其他组中均观察到LV功能的显著降低。对力 - 速度和长度 - 张力关系的检查证实,第一组和第二组(4℃多剂量K)的心肌性能优于第三组和第四组(4℃缓冲盐水)。第一组和第三组(持续交叉阻断)在交叉阻断后LV舒张顺应性没有降低,而在较高前负荷下,第二组和第四组(间歇性交叉阻断)的顺应性均降低(分别为p<0.05和p<0.025)。第一组和第三组(持续交叉阻断)的心肌湿重/干重比低于第二组和第四组(间歇性交叉阻断)。尽管所有组中磷酸肌酸(CP)浓度通过再灌注迅速恢复,但在交叉阻断结束时,第一组和第二组(4℃多剂量K)的三磷酸腺苷(ATP)和糖原心肌储备保存得更好。尽管第二组和第四组(间歇性交叉阻断)的LV舒张顺应性降低且心肌含水量增加,但在电子显微镜检查的任何组中,心内膜下出血、水肿和收缩带坏死的最小程度均未观察到差异。本研究确定持续主动脉交叉阻断并在4℃给予多剂量K是一种更好的心肌保护方法。