Nelson J D, Kusmiesz H, Jackson L H, Woodman E
Pediatrics. 1980 Jun;65(6):1125-30.
In a randomized, prospective, double-blind study infants and children with uncomplicated Salmonella gastroenteritis were treated with ampicillin (15 patients), amoxicillin (15 patients), or placebo (14 patients). The dosage of antibiotics was 100 mg/kg/day in four equally divided doses given for five days. There was no significant benefit from antibiotic therapy on the duration of diarrhea (means 8.8, 7.3, and 7.2 days, respectively) or on the duration of recovery of Salmonella from stool cultures (means 41.3, 37.0, and 20.9 days, respectively). Bacteriologic relapse was not observed in placebo-treated patients but eight patients given ampicillin (53%) and eight given amoxicillin (53%) had relapse (P = .003). Salmonella isolated in relapse were still susceptible in vitro to the antibiotics. Of the 16 patients with bacteriologic relapse six (38%) had concomitant recurrence of diarrhea. It is concluded that ampicillin or amoxicillin therapy provides no benefit to patients with uncomplicated Salmonella gastroenteritis and substantially increases the risk of bacteriologic and symptomatic relapse.
在一项随机、前瞻性、双盲研究中,对患有非复杂性沙门氏菌肠胃炎的婴幼儿和儿童分别用氨苄西林(15例患者)、阿莫西林(15例患者)或安慰剂(14例患者)进行治疗。抗生素剂量为每日100mg/kg,分4等份剂量给药,持续5天。抗生素治疗在腹泻持续时间(分别为8.8天、7.3天和7.2天)或粪便培养中沙门氏菌恢复持续时间(分别为41.3天、37.0天和20.9天)方面均无显著益处。接受安慰剂治疗的患者未观察到细菌学复发,但8例接受氨苄西林治疗的患者(53%)和8例接受阿莫西林治疗的患者(53%)出现复发(P = 0.003)。复发时分离出的沙门氏菌在体外仍对这些抗生素敏感。在16例细菌学复发的患者中,6例(38%)同时出现腹泻复发。得出的结论是,氨苄西林或阿莫西林治疗对患有非复杂性沙门氏菌肠胃炎的患者没有益处,且会大幅增加细菌学和症状性复发的风险。