Curran W P, Woodward E P
Am J Sports Med. 1980 Nov-Dec;8(6):415-8. doi: 10.1177/036354658000800606.
The authors performed 396 knee arthroscopies on athletic patients under general or spinal anesthesia. One hundred-fifty patients underwent arthroscopy after a careful history and physical examination. The clinical diagnosis was correct in 97 patients, correct but incomplete in 25 patients, and incorrect in 28 patients. Our total clinical accuracy rate was 71%. Arthroscopy increased accuracy from 71 to 97%. The remaining 153 patients had knee arthrography before undergoing diagnostic arthroscopy. The arthrographic accuracy rate for the medial compartment was 63% and for the lateral compartment was 36%. Arthroscopic accuracy rate for these patients was 95% for the medial and 97% for the lateral compartments. Two hundred of the 250 arthroscopies were followed by immediate arthrotomy. There were no deep or superficial infections. Arthroscopy, when compared to our clinical impression and arthrography, was the most accurate diagnostic aid. Using it we made the correct diagnosis in 392 out of 396 patients.
作者对接受全身麻醉或脊髓麻醉的运动患者进行了396例膝关节镜检查。150例患者在经过仔细的病史询问和体格检查后接受了关节镜检查。临床诊断在97例患者中正确,在25例患者中正确但不完整,在28例患者中错误。我们总的临床准确率为71%。关节镜检查将准确率从71%提高到了97%。其余153例患者在进行诊断性关节镜检查前进行了膝关节造影。内侧间室的关节造影准确率为63%,外侧间室为36%。这些患者的关节镜检查内侧间室准确率为95%,外侧间室为97%。250例关节镜检查中有200例随后立即进行了关节切开术。没有深部或浅表感染。与我们的临床印象和关节造影相比,关节镜检查是最准确的诊断辅助手段。使用关节镜检查,我们在396例患者中的392例做出了正确诊断。