Wells R A, Dezen A E
Fam Process. 1978 Sep;17(3):251-74. doi: 10.1111/j.1545-5300.1978.00251.x.
Studies from 1971 to 1976 reporting on the outcome of the nonbehavioral family therapies are analyzed and critically reviewed. Such research has increased in both quality and quantity since 1970 and, broadly speaking, has legitimized the status of family therapy as a viable mode of helping. Particularly potent effects were noted for family therapy as an alternative to psychiatric hospitalization, with psychosomatic problems in children and adolescents, and in certain applications with parent-child and parent-adolescent relationships. However, a number of studies comparing family therapy with no formal treatment or an alternative treatment found little difference in outcome. Problems in family therapy outcome research are discussed and some future directions suggested.
对1971年至1976年期间有关非行为家庭疗法结果的研究进行了分析和批判性审查。自1970年以来,此类研究在质量和数量上均有所增加,从广义上讲,已使家庭疗法作为一种可行的帮助模式的地位合法化。家庭疗法作为精神病住院治疗的替代方法、对儿童和青少年的心身问题以及在某些亲子和青少年与父母关系的应用中,显示出特别显著的效果。然而,一些将家庭疗法与无正规治疗或替代治疗进行比较的研究发现,结果差异不大。讨论了家庭疗法结果研究中的问题,并提出了一些未来的方向。