Maier U, Holub G, Krepler R
Wien Klin Wochenschr. 1980 Nov 21;92(22):803-5.
Over a period of four years 352 patients suspected of having a carcinoma of the prostate were investigated and 463 cytological and 343 histological examinations were undertaken. In 340 cases the cytological findings on transrectal aspiration biopsy according to Franzen [14] were compared with the histological findings on transperineal punch biopsy. This comparison showed an accuracy of 64.5% and if the PAP III findings were included, of 76.6% in diagnosing prostatic carcinoma by the cytological method. Since the majority of cases were first biopsies and a repeat biopsy was not made in view of the positive punch findings, the chances of detecting a carcinoma of the prostate by aspiration biopsy alone theoretically increase to almost 90%. The reasons for failures in concurrence of findings by the two methods are discussed.
在四年的时间里,对352名疑似患有前列腺癌的患者进行了调查,并进行了463次细胞学检查和343次组织学检查。在340例病例中,将根据弗兰岑[14]法经直肠穿刺活检的细胞学检查结果与经会阴穿刺活检的组织学检查结果进行了比较。这种比较显示,通过细胞学方法诊断前列腺癌的准确率为64.5%,如果将PAP III的结果包括在内,则为76.6%。由于大多数病例是首次活检,并且鉴于穿刺活检结果呈阳性而未进行重复活检,理论上仅通过穿刺活检检测前列腺癌的几率几乎增加到90%。讨论了两种方法检查结果不一致的原因。