Nieder J, Lattorff E
Zentralbl Gynakol. 1980;102(2):84-92.
Foetal condition and neonatal mortality of 637 prematurely born children with birth weights below 2,501 g were analysed, depending on modes of delivery, such as spontaneous birth, speculum delivery, use of forceps, manual support, and caesarean section. The clinical condition of the newborn, assessed five minutes from parturition by Apgar score 1, was found to depend primarily on birth weight rather than on the mode of delivery. The average Apgar values were lower for less mature newborns. While Apgar scores were worst for newborns after caesarean section delivery, the differences between approaches to delivery could not be statistically secured. Neonatal mortality went up, according to expectation, along with dropping birth weight. The mortality rate of premature births below 1,501 g was not affected by delivery modes. Prophylactic use of Shute forceps and speculum delivery appeared to be superior to spontaneous birth in the medium weight class, between 1,501 g and 2,000 g. Yet, not even here were the differences between clear postnatal mortality rates statistically secured. -Lowest mortality figures were recorded from spontaneous birth in the weight class between 2,001 g and 2,500 g, but significant differences were established only to speculum delivery. Premature newborns after caesarean section had poorer prospects than all variants of vaginal birth, but among the latter premature births from breech presentation were more endangered than others. Decisions as to vaginal, abdominal, spontaneous proprophylactically surgical approaches to premature deliveries should be taken for every individual case and due consideration of many factors.
分析了637名出生体重低于2501克的早产儿的胎儿状况和新生儿死亡率,具体取决于分娩方式,如自然分娩、窥器助产、使用产钳、手法辅助以及剖宫产。通过出生后5分钟的阿氏评分1评估新生儿的临床状况,结果发现主要取决于出生体重而非分娩方式。成熟度较低的新生儿平均阿氏评分较低。虽然剖宫产分娩后的新生儿阿氏评分最差,但不同分娩方式之间的差异在统计学上并不显著。正如预期的那样,新生儿死亡率随着出生体重的下降而上升。出生体重低于1501克的早产儿死亡率不受分娩方式的影响。在体重介于1501克至2000克的中等体重类别中,预防性使用舒特产钳和窥器助产似乎优于自然分娩。然而,即使在此处,产后死亡率的明显差异在统计学上也不显著。出生体重在2001克至2500克之间的类别中,自然分娩的死亡率最低,但仅与窥器助产有显著差异。剖宫产术后的早产儿预后比所有阴道分娩方式都差,但在后者中,臀位早产比其他情况更危险。对于早产的阴道、腹部、自然或预防性手术分娩方式的决策,应针对每个具体病例并充分考虑多种因素。