Welbourn C R, Haworth J M, Leaper D J, Thompson M H
Department of Surgery, Southmead Hospital, Bristol, UK.
Br J Surg. 1995 Oct;82(10):1371-3. doi: 10.1002/bjs.1800821026.
Current means of predicting the presence of bile duct stones are sensitive but produce a large number of false-positive results, potentially leading to added morbidity from unnecessary invasive investigation. This study prospectively assessed 545 patients with gallbladder stones, including 55 patients with bile duct stones, to refine criteria for further investigation of the bile duct. The sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values were calculated for bile duct dilatation (diameter abnormal if larger than 5 mm below age 50 years, normal value increasing by 1 mm per decade) and elevation of three liver function tests, singly or in combination. Depending on the number of abnormalities used the sensitivity ranged from 46 to 96 per cent and the positive predictive value from 35 to 77 per cent. All groupings gave at least 96 per cent negative predictive value for the absence of stones but none combined both high sensitivity and positive predictive value. The specificity was improved if the tests were done on the working day before operation. Refining criteria for predicting bile duct stones allows the selective use of cholangiography and may reduce the number of negative cholangiograms.
目前预测胆管结石存在的方法具有敏感性,但会产生大量假阳性结果,这可能会因不必要的侵入性检查而增加发病率。本研究前瞻性地评估了545例胆囊结石患者,其中包括55例胆管结石患者,以完善胆管进一步检查的标准。计算了胆管扩张(50岁以下患者直径大于5mm为异常,正常数值每十年增加1mm)和三项肝功能检查单独或联合升高的敏感性、特异性、阳性预测值和阴性预测值。根据所使用异常情况的数量,敏感性范围为46%至96%,阳性预测值范围为35%至77%。所有分组对无结石的阴性预测值均至少为96%,但没有一组同时具备高敏感性和高阳性预测值。如果在手术前的工作日进行检查,特异性会提高。完善预测胆管结石的标准可使胆管造影检查得以选择性使用,并可能减少阴性胆管造影的数量。