Ando N, Ozawa S, Kitajima M, Iizuka T
Dept. of Surgery, School of Medicine, Keio University, Japan.
Gan To Kagaku Ryoho. 1995 Jun;22(7):869-76.
Many single-agent phase II studies for patients with esophageal cancer had been performed, and at least five agents with modest activity have been indentified, BLM, MMC, CDDP, VDS and MTX, that revealed no CR. Even in the phase II study of 254-S, a new anticancer platinum complex, with a response rate of 43%, CR could not be recognized. Only two regimens of combination chemotherapy have been studied extensively, CDDP/BLM/VDS and CDDP/5-FU. The combination of CDDP/5-FU has gained popularity and JEOG phase II study revealed a response rate of 36%. As surgical adjuvant therapy, postoperative adjuvant therapy has been common in Japan. The 4th JEOG phase III clinical trial, comparing surgery alone and postoperative chemotherapy of CDDP/VDS, showed no additive effect to surgery by postoperative chemotherapy with such a regimen. In western countries, neoadjuvant chemotherapy is frequent and most of the regimens include CDDP/5-FU. Pathological CR rates were less than 10%, and median survival terms were from eight to 28 months. The rationale for the concurrent use of chemotherapy and radiotherapy is to combine an agent that has an effect upon systemic micrometastases with a modality that enhances local tumor control. In addition, a number of chemotherapeutic agents have radiosensitizing effects. In western countries, more than 35 trials studying over 1400 patients have been reported. The majority of trials have employed CDDP/5-FU combined with RT to a total dose of 30Gy. Pathological CR rates were from 20 to 40% and median survival terms were from 12 to 29 months. Both neoadjuvant chemotherapy and chemoradiotherapy did not change operative morbidity or mortality, and there was a statistically significant increase in survival in complete responders. However, early and median survival seems improved but cure rates are not. Both therapies require further investigation.
已经开展了许多针对食管癌患者的单药II期研究,并且已经确定了至少五种具有一定活性的药物,即博来霉素(BLM)、丝裂霉素(MMC)、顺铂(CDDP)、长春地辛(VDS)和甲氨蝶呤(MTX),但均未出现完全缓解(CR)。即使在新的抗癌铂类复合物254-S的II期研究中,其缓解率为43%,也未观察到完全缓解。仅对两种联合化疗方案进行了广泛研究,即顺铂/博来霉素/长春地辛(CDDP/BLM/VDS)和顺铂/氟尿嘧啶(CDDP/5-FU)。顺铂/氟尿嘧啶联合方案已得到广泛应用,日本食管癌研究组(JEOG)的II期研究显示其缓解率为36%。作为手术辅助治疗,术后辅助治疗在日本很常见。日本食管癌研究组的第4项III期临床试验比较了单纯手术与顺铂/长春地辛术后化疗,结果显示该化疗方案对手术并无附加疗效。在西方国家,新辅助化疗很常见,大多数方案都包括顺铂/氟尿嘧啶。病理完全缓解率低于10%,中位生存期为8至28个月。化疗与放疗同时使用的基本原理是将对全身微转移有效的药物与增强局部肿瘤控制的方式相结合。此外,许多化疗药物具有放射增敏作用。在西方国家,已经报道了35多项试验,研究对象超过1400例。大多数试验采用顺铂/氟尿嘧啶联合放疗,总剂量为30Gy。病理完全缓解率为20%至40%,中位生存期为12至29个月。新辅助化疗和放化疗均未改变手术的发病率或死亡率,完全缓解者的生存率有统计学意义的提高。然而,早期和中位生存期似乎有所改善,但治愈率并未提高。这两种治疗方法都需要进一步研究。