Paauw D S, Wenrich M D, Curtis J R, Carline J D, Ramsey P G
Department of Medicine, University of Washington School of Medicine, Seattle, USA.
JAMA. 1995 Nov 1;274(17):1380-2.
To assess the ability of primary care physicians to identify physical findings associated with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection.
Standardized patient examination.
A total of 134 general internists and family practitioners were randomly selected after stratifying by year of medical school graduation, specialty, and experience caring for patients with HIV infection.
Recognition of physical findings of Kaposi's sarcoma, oral hairy leukoplakia, and diffuse lymphadenopathy.
Despite being directed by presenting histories to sites of prominent physical abnormalities, only 23 (25.8%) of 89 physicians evaluating a patient with Kaposi's sarcoma and 22 (22.7%) of 97 physicians evaluating a patient with oral hairy leukoplakia detected and correctly diagnosed the abnormalities. Twenty-three (17%) of 133 physicians detected diffuse lymphadenopathy in a patient complaining of fatigue, fever, and arthralgias. Physicians with the most experience treating patients with HIV infection more frequently identified oral hairy leukoplakia, but HIV experience did not influence identification of Kaposi's sarcoma or detection of lymphadenopathy. There were no differences between general internists and family practitioners or among physicians by year of medical school graduation in identifying the three physical findings associated with HIV infection.
Primary care physicians may frequently miss important physical findings related to HIV infection during patient examinations.
评估基层医疗医生识别与人类免疫缺陷病毒(HIV)感染相关体征的能力。
标准化患者检查。
根据医学院毕业年份、专业以及照顾HIV感染患者的经验进行分层后,随机选取了134名普通内科医生和家庭医生。
识别卡波西肉瘤、口腔毛状白斑和弥漫性淋巴结病的体征。
尽管根据现病史提示了明显身体异常部位,但在评估卡波西肉瘤患者的89名医生中,只有23名(25.8%)检测并正确诊断出了异常;在评估口腔毛状白斑患者的97名医生中,只有22名(22.7%)做到了这一点。在一名主诉疲劳、发热和关节痛的患者中,133名医生中有23名(17%)检测出了弥漫性淋巴结病。治疗HIV感染患者经验最丰富的医生更常识别出口腔毛状白斑,但HIV治疗经验并未影响卡波西肉瘤的识别或淋巴结病的检测。在识别与HIV感染相关的这三种体征方面,普通内科医生和家庭医生之间以及不同医学院毕业年份的医生之间没有差异。
基层医疗医生在患者检查过程中可能经常遗漏与HIV感染相关的重要体征。