Ribacke M
Department of Family Medicine, University of Uppsala, Sweden.
Scand J Prim Health Care. 1995 Jun;13(2):112-7. doi: 10.3109/02813439508996746.
To examine test ordering practice among general practitioners and hospital medical specialists according to the concept of individualized hypertension care.
Mailed hypothetical case histories, with reference panels to categorize tests.
Uppsala-Orebro region in mid-Sweden.
General practitioners (N = 90) and hospital medical specialists (N = 69) in randomly sampled primary health care centres and hospitals.
Test ordering scores.
84% of invited GPs and 72% of specialists participated. According to reference panel standards, primary care physicians performed 75% of obligatory tests and specialists 88%. Superfluous tests constituted a larger proportion of the practice of hospital specialists (11-28%) than GPs (2-12%) in the six cases. Summarized examination scores revealed a wide practice variation within and between the two physician categories, specialists scoring significantly higher in three cases. Standardization of practice was more common among specialists, and differed significantly regarding serum potassium test, chest X-ray and ECG. Both groups deviated from current guidelines by omitting metabolic parameters.
There is considerable practice variation in individualized hypertension care, which might influence treatment outcome. Practice audit and continuing medical education could contribute to care standardization according to guidelines.
根据个体化高血压护理的概念,研究全科医生和医院医学专家的检查开单行为。
邮寄假设病例史,并提供参考标准以对检查进行分类。
瑞典中部的乌普萨拉-厄勒布鲁地区。
从随机抽取的初级卫生保健中心和医院中选取的全科医生(N = 90)和医院医学专家(N = 69)。
检查开单分数。
84% 的受邀全科医生和72% 的专家参与了研究。根据参考标准,初级保健医生完成了75% 的必要检查,专家完成了88%。在六个病例中,不必要检查在医院专家的诊疗行为中所占比例(11 - 28%)高于全科医生(2 - 12%)。汇总的检查分数显示,两类医生内部和之间的诊疗行为差异很大,在三个病例中专家的得分显著更高。诊疗行为的标准化在专家中更为常见,在血清钾检查、胸部X光和心电图方面存在显著差异。两组都因遗漏代谢参数而偏离了当前指南。
个体化高血压护理的诊疗行为存在很大差异,这可能会影响治疗结果。实践审核和继续医学教育有助于按照指南实现护理标准化。