Cohn K, Kamm B, Feteih N, Brand R, Goldschlager N
Circulation. 1979 Feb;59(2):286-96. doi: 10.1161/01.cir.59.2.286.
In this study we assessed whether various responses to exercise testing could be quantified in order to derive the probabilities of presence of coronary disease, and if present, to assess its severity. A treadmill score based on the exercise response was determined in 405 patients who had both treadmill tests and coronary angiograms. The score was derived using discriminant function analysis, by weighting and combining depth and configuration of ST depression (downsloping, horizontal or slowly upsloping), timing onset and duration of ischemia, grading ventricular arrhythmias, heart rate and blood pressure change, coexistence of exercise-induced chest pain and sex. The treadmill score was effective in detecting coronary disease (lesions with an greater than or equal to 50% narrowing), with a predictive accuracy (PA) (probability that a subject manifesting a positive test has disease) of 87%, a true negative rate (TNR) (probability of a subject with a negative test having no disease) of 80%, and sensitivity of 94%. The treadmill score also detected severe disease (triple-vessel, main left and/or greater than 90% proximal occlusion of the left anterior descending artery), with a PA of 73%, TNR of 79% and sensitivity of 82%. We conclude that the exercise response, expressed numerically as a treadmill score, permits analysis of most of the relevant data from exercise testing, increases test accuracy by 10-15% compared with standard criteria for treatmill test interpretation, and enables the derivation of probability statements for presence and severity of coronary disease. The validity of any prediction on the basis of exercise performance may thus be quantitatively judged.
在本研究中,我们评估了是否可以对运动测试的各种反应进行量化,以便得出冠心病存在的概率,若存在冠心病,则评估其严重程度。在405名既进行了跑步机测试又进行了冠状动脉造影的患者中,根据运动反应确定了跑步机评分。该评分通过判别函数分析得出,对ST段压低的深度和形态(下斜型、水平型或缓慢上斜型)、缺血发作时间和持续时间、室性心律失常分级、心率和血压变化、运动诱发胸痛的共存情况以及性别进行加权和综合计算。跑步机评分在检测冠心病(狭窄≥50%的病变)方面有效,预测准确率(PA)(测试呈阳性的受试者患有疾病的概率)为87%,真阴性率(TNR)(测试呈阴性的受试者无疾病的概率)为80%,敏感性为94%。跑步机评分还能检测出严重疾病(三支血管病变、左主干和/或左前降支近端闭塞≥90%),PA为73%,TNR为79%,敏感性为82%。我们得出结论,以跑步机评分的数字形式表示的运动反应,允许对运动测试的大多数相关数据进行分析,与跑步机测试解释的标准标准相比,测试准确性提高了10 - 15%,并能够得出冠心病存在和严重程度的概率陈述。因此,可以对基于运动表现的任何预测的有效性进行定量判断。