Feldstein T J, Swegarden J L, Atwood G F, Peterson C D
Department of Clinical Pharmacy, MeritCare Childrens Hospital, Fargo, ND, USA.
Pediatrics. 1995 Jul;96(1 Pt 1):14-7.
The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recommends that ribavirin be reserved for infants who are severely ill and who are at high risk of morbidity and mortality, based on underlying clinical conditions. The purpose of this study was to evaluate current ribavirin use in our institution, implement hospital-specific guidelines for use, develop a prospective surveillance system to monitor ribavirin therapy, and evaluate the impact of these guidelines on subsequent use and cost of therapy.
Ribavirin use was compared with the recommendations of the AAP. Results were presented to the professional staff, and hospital guidelines were implemented. Ribavirin therapy was reevaluated in a 2-year period after hospital guidelines were implemented.
In the initial evaluation period, only 67% of the ribavirin recipients met the AAP guidelines for use, and 19% received an inappropriate treatment regimen. The total cost and billed patient charges for ribavirin recipients who did not meet the guidelines for use in period 1 was $60,638 and $127,940, respectively. Over the next 2 years (period 2) after the implementation of hospital guidelines, the percentage of patients who received ribavirin decreased 35%, and approximately 96% of ribavirin recipients met the established criteria. Based on the decrease in the percentage of patients who received ribavirin in period 2 (41% versus 63%), the estimated cost avoidance and reduction in billed patient charges in period 2 was $55,540 and $117,334, respectively. This represents an estimated reduction in hospital costs and billed patient charges of $46,283 and $97,778 per 100 admissions for acute bronchiolitis.
Before the implementation of hospital guidelines for use, a substantial percent of patients received ribavirin not consistent with the recommendations of the AAP. Following the adoption of a modified version of the AAP guidelines for our institution and the use of a multidisciplinary surveillance system for monitoring ribavirin therapy, we observed a substantial decrease in the overall ribavirin use. This has resulted in a significant savings in terms of cost avoidance and reduced billed patient charges.
美国儿科学会(AAP)建议,基于潜在临床状况,利巴韦林应仅用于重症且有高发病和死亡风险的婴儿。本研究的目的是评估我院当前利巴韦林的使用情况,实施医院特定的使用指南,建立前瞻性监测系统以监测利巴韦林治疗,并评估这些指南对后续使用及治疗费用的影响。
将利巴韦林的使用情况与AAP的建议进行比较。结果反馈给专业人员,并实施医院指南。在实施医院指南后的两年内对利巴韦林治疗进行重新评估。
在初始评估期,仅67%的利巴韦林接受者符合AAP的使用指南,19%接受了不恰当的治疗方案。第1期不符合使用指南的利巴韦林接受者的总成本和患者计费分别为60638美元和127940美元。在实施医院指南后的接下来两年(第2期),接受利巴韦林治疗的患者比例下降了35%,约96%的利巴韦林接受者符合既定标准。基于第2期接受利巴韦林治疗患者比例的下降(41%对63%),第2期估计避免的费用和减少的患者计费分别为55540美元和117334美元。这意味着每100例急性细支气管炎入院病例估计可减少医院成本和患者计费46283美元和97778美元。
在实施医院使用指南之前,相当一部分患者接受的利巴韦林治疗不符合AAP的建议。在采用我院修改后的AAP指南并使用多学科监测系统监测利巴韦林治疗后,我们观察到利巴韦林的总体使用量大幅下降。这在避免费用和减少患者计费方面节省了大量资金。