Nankivell B J, Gruenewald S M, Allen R D, Chapman J R
Department of Renal Medicine, Westmead Hospital, Sydney, Australia.
Transplantation. 1995 Jun 27;59(12):1683-9. doi: 10.1097/00007890-199506270-00007.
Serum creatinine is an important clinical measure of impairment of glomerular filtration rate (GFR) after kidney transplantation. The use of formulas that predict GFR (such as the Cockcroft-Gault) derived from patients with chronic renal failure and standardized against measured creatinine clearance may not be accurate when applied to kidney transplant recipients. The purpose of this study, was to investigate the level of inaccuracy and its causes and then to derive predictive GFR formulas that are appropriate to renal transplantation. Determinants of isotopic GFR, serum creatinine, and muscle mass were evaluated in consecutive kidney recipients (n = 146) using 99mTc DTPA GFR (n = 751) as a reference method. Factors that predicted GFR apart from serum creatinine included sex, height, body weight, serum urea, years on dialysis, numbers of rejections and infective episodes, and prednisolone dose. The relationship between serum creatinine and GFR was highly variable and dependent on factors that alter muscle mass and muscle catabolic rate. The relationship was further altered by ATN and chronic rejection when tubular secretion of creatinine was reduced. Three alternative GFR formulas (which can be applied to renal transplant patients according to the availability of clinical parameters) were derived and tested against six published methods of GFR estimation. Our derived formulas had the highest correlation, no overall bias, least scatter of sum of squares, and least error at low levels of GFR. They represent a better estimation of GFR in kidney transplantation than published formulas, and would allow a standardized approach to the study of long-term renal dysfunction.
血清肌酐是肾移植后肾小球滤过率(GFR)受损的一项重要临床指标。对于慢性肾衰竭患者所推导并根据测量的肌酐清除率进行标准化的预测GFR的公式(如Cockcroft-Gault公式),应用于肾移植受者时可能并不准确。本研究的目的是调查其不准确程度及其原因,进而推导适用于肾移植的预测GFR公式。使用99mTc DTPA GFR(n = 751)作为参考方法,对连续的肾移植受者(n = 146)的同位素GFR、血清肌酐和肌肉量的决定因素进行了评估。除血清肌酐外,预测GFR的因素还包括性别、身高、体重、血清尿素、透析年限、排斥反应和感染发作次数以及泼尼松龙剂量。血清肌酐与GFR之间的关系高度可变,且取决于改变肌肉量和肌肉分解代谢率的因素。当肌酐的肾小管分泌减少时,急性肾小管坏死和慢性排斥反应会进一步改变这种关系。推导了三个可供选择的GFR公式(可根据临床参数的可获得性应用于肾移植患者),并与六种已发表的GFR估算方法进行了对比测试。我们推导的公式具有最高的相关性、无总体偏差、最小的平方和离散度以及在低GFR水平时最小的误差。与已发表的公式相比,它们在肾移植中对GFR的估计更好,并且将为长期肾功能障碍的研究提供一种标准化方法。