Marleau J D, Roy R, Laporte L, Webanck T, Poulin B
Faculte de médecine, Université de Montréal, Québec.
Can J Psychiatry. 1995 Apr;40(3):142-9.
Using data gathered at the Institut Philippe Pinel in Montréal, we shall describe the sociodemographic and psychiatric profile of a sample of 17 women who have killed (n = 14) or attempted to kill (n = 3) one of their children. Our data indicate that women who have committed this type of offence generally come from a disadvantaged socioeconomic environment. Most have a psychiatric history (evaluation and/or hospitalization). Review of the offence demonstrates that most women do not use a weapon to kill their child; the preferred methods are strangulation or drowning. Most of these offences may be classified as extended suicide or altruistic acts. Several of the women present with a severe personality disorder and an additional depressive episode in the context of the offence. We hope our study will help clarify understanding of filicide and assist in the development of certain prevention axes. These results indicate that the population at large and various intervenors in our society (family physicians, psychiatrists, criminologists, social workers, pediatricians, psychologists, gynecologists) must become increasingly vigilant and avoid trivialization of signals such as verbalization of homicidal thoughts about the child or recourse to certain disorganized behaviours.
利用在蒙特利尔菲利普·皮内尔研究所收集的数据,我们将描述17名杀害(n = 14)或企图杀害(n = 3)自己孩子的女性样本的社会人口统计学和精神病学特征。我们的数据表明,犯下这类罪行的女性通常来自社会经济弱势环境。大多数人有精神病史(接受过评估和/或住院治疗)。对这些罪行的审查表明,大多数女性并非使用武器杀害自己的孩子;最常用的方法是勒死或溺死。这些罪行大多可归类为扩大性自杀或利他行为。其中几名女性在犯罪时伴有严重的人格障碍和额外的抑郁发作。我们希望我们的研究将有助于阐明对杀子行为的理解,并协助制定某些预防措施。这些结果表明,广大公众以及我们社会中的各类干预者(家庭医生、精神科医生、犯罪学家、社会工作者、儿科医生、心理学家、妇科医生)必须提高警惕,避免轻视诸如表达杀害孩子的想法或采取某些无组织行为等信号。