Kuhs H, Folkerts H
Psychiatric Department, University of Münster, Germany.
Neuropsychobiology. 1995;31(3):135-45. doi: 10.1159/000119184.
22 acutely schizophrenic patients with partial remission under standard haloperidol therapy (reduction in BPRS total score by 50% or less) were included in this prospective study. There was a significant correlation between the BPRS total score or the BPRS factors Anxiety/depression and Anergia and extrapyramidal side effects at the end of the 3-week neuroleptic treatment phase. In these patients abrupt discontinuation of neuroleptic medication (suspension therapy) brings about a significant further reduction in BPRS total scores together with a favorable effect on the BPRS factors Anxiety/depression, Anergia and Thought disturbance. There was a trend towards low serum prolactin values before neuroleptic discontinuation being linked with a favorable effect of subsequent suspension therapy. Urinary dopamine and homovanillic acid excretion before neuroleptic discontinuation did not predict the clinical suspension effect. Thus peripheral neuroendocrine and biochemical effects of haloperidol-induced dopamine blockade and their changes after discontinuation of neuroleptic medication seem not to be linked with the clinical effect of suspension therapy in acute schizophrenia. There was, however, a significant relationship between low urinary epinephrine, norepinephrine, vanillylmandelic acid and cortisol excretion before suspension therapy and a favorable suspension effect. On the other hand, the more pronounced a nonspecific stress constellation (catecholamines, cortisol) was in patients with an unsatisfactory remission under neuroleptics, the less favorable was the clinical effect of suspension therapy. Until now, the treatment courses of suspension therapy have been evaluated in 43 schizophrenic patients. According to both clinical aspects and observer rating, three types of therapeutic suspension effects have been distinguished in one-third of the cases respectively; none (at best temporary remission, no improvement in the overall treatment situation); partial (substantial remission, neuroleptic medication resumed for therapeutic reasons), and favorable (almost complete remission, neuroleptic medication resumed for prophylactic reasons).
22例在标准氟哌啶醇治疗下处于部分缓解状态(简明精神病评定量表总分降低50%或更少)的急性精神分裂症患者被纳入这项前瞻性研究。在为期3周的抗精神病药物治疗阶段结束时,简明精神病评定量表总分或其焦虑/抑郁及无动力因素与锥体外系副作用之间存在显著相关性。在这些患者中,突然停用抗精神病药物(停药疗法)可使简明精神病评定量表总分进一步显著降低,并对简明精神病评定量表的焦虑/抑郁、无动力及思维紊乱因素产生有利影响。在停用抗精神病药物前血清催乳素值较低有与随后停药疗法产生有利影响相关的趋势。停用抗精神病药物前尿多巴胺和高香草酸排泄量不能预测临床停药效果。因此,氟哌啶醇引起的多巴胺阻断的外周神经内分泌和生化效应及其在停用抗精神病药物后的变化似乎与急性精神分裂症停药疗法的临床效果无关。然而,在停药疗法前尿肾上腺素、去甲肾上腺素、香草扁桃酸和皮质醇排泄量较低与有利的停药效果之间存在显著关系。另一方面,在使用抗精神病药物治疗缓解不充分的患者中,非特异性应激状态(儿茶酚胺、皮质醇)越明显,停药疗法的临床效果越差。到目前为止,已对43例精神分裂症患者的停药治疗过程进行了评估。根据临床情况和观察者评分,分别在三分之一的病例中区分出三种类型的治疗停药效果;无(充其量是暂时缓解,整体治疗情况无改善);部分(显著缓解,因治疗原因恢复使用抗精神病药物)和有利(几乎完全缓解,因预防原因恢复使用抗精神病药物)。