Ritsema G H, Polder J J
St. Clara Ziekenhuis, afd. Radiodiagnostiek, Rotterdam.
Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd. 1995 Jul 8;139(27):1386-90.
To determine whether compression ultrasound examination of both legs, to detect deep venous thrombosis, can be the examination of first choice in patients clinically suspected of pulmonary embolism, assuming that the therapy of thrombosis is the same as the therapy of embolism.
Prospective study.
St. Clara Hospital, Rotterdam, the Netherlands.
337 consecutive patients (157 women and 180 men, mean age 65 years, SD: 17.4) suspected of pulmonary embolism underwent compression ultrasound examination of the femoral and popliteal veins to detect deep venous thrombosis, and perfusion lung scintigraphy, with ventilation scintigraphy if indicated. Ultrasound examinations and lung scans were interpreted independently and blinded. A financial analysis of the various strategies was made.
Deep venous thrombosis was demonstrated ultrasonographically in four (2%) of 208 patients with a normal lung scan, in four (9%) of 43 patients with a non-diagnostic lung scan, and in 30 (35%) of 86 patients with a high probability lung scan. By starting the diagnostic investigation with ultrasound examination 38 lung scans and chest X-rays would be saved at the cost of 294 extra ultrasound examinations. Because ultrasound examinations are relatively inexpensive a cost reduction of 3.4% would be realised, for the Netherlands approximately 1.4 million guilders. In the United States, however, costs would increase because of the high prices of ultrasound examinations.
Compression ultrasound examination of both legs can be the examination of first choice in the Netherlands in patients suspected of pulmonary embolism, as it is cost effective.
假设血栓形成的治疗与肺栓塞的治疗相同,确定对双腿进行加压超声检查以检测深静脉血栓形成是否可以作为临床疑似肺栓塞患者的首选检查方法。
前瞻性研究。
荷兰鹿特丹圣克拉拉医院。
337例连续的临床疑似肺栓塞患者(157例女性,180例男性,平均年龄65岁,标准差:17.4)接受了股静脉和腘静脉的加压超声检查以检测深静脉血栓形成,并进行了灌注肺闪烁扫描,必要时进行通气闪烁扫描。超声检查和肺部扫描由独立的、不知情的人员解读。对各种策略进行了财务分析。
在208例肺部扫描正常的患者中,超声检查发现4例(2%)存在深静脉血栓形成;在43例肺部扫描无法诊断的患者中,4例(9%)存在深静脉血栓形成;在86例肺部扫描高度可疑的患者中,30例(35%)存在深静脉血栓形成。通过首先进行超声检查开始诊断性调查,可节省38次肺部扫描和胸部X光检查,但代价是额外增加294次超声检查。由于超声检查相对便宜,成本将降低3.4%,对荷兰来说约为140万荷兰盾。然而,在美国,由于超声检查价格高昂,成本将会增加。
对双腿进行加压超声检查对荷兰疑似肺栓塞的患者来说可以作为首选检查方法,因为它具有成本效益。