Liao Z X, Travis E L, Tucker S L
Department of Experimental Radiotherapy, University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center, Houston 77030, USA.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 1995 Jul 30;32(5):1359-70. doi: 10.1016/0360-3016(94)00660-D.
The aims of this study were to: (a) define the relationship of dose and volume irradiated to damage and morbidity in mouse lung, (b) determine the threshold volume for morbidity after partial lung irradiation; and (c) determine whether the response to radiation of mouse lung is independent of the region irradiated.
C3Hf/Kam female mice were used in this study. The fractional volume of the lung to be irradiated was determined by two methods, weights and computed tomography (CT) scanning. Two experiments were performed to define the volume effect and to determine whether the response of the mouse lung to radiation was homogeneous. In the first experiment, single doses of x-rays ranging from 12 to 20 Gy were given to partial volumes of 84%, 70%, and 40% including the base, 50%, 33%, and 17% including the apex, to 43% in the middle, and to the sum of 57% as 17% in the apex and 40% in the base. In the second experiment, the same volumes of 50% and 70-75% in the apex and base of the lung were irradiated with single doses ranging from 12-19.25 Gy. Morbidity from radiation pneumonitis was quantitated by two end points, breathing rate and lethality between 12 and 32 weeks after irradiation. Damage was assessed by histopathological evidence of pneumonitis.
Clear well-defined dose-response curves were obtained for both breathing rate and lethality after all volumes irradiated. There was a clear volume-dependent shift of the dose-response curves for breathing rate and lethality at 28 weeks after irradiation, the end of the pneumonitis phase of damage, to higher doses compared with these data after whole-lung irradiation. In addition, the slopes of the dose-response curves for irradiation of partial lung volumes were more shallow compared to those after whole-lung irradiation. Increases in breathing rate correlated with lethality when the volume irradiated was equal to or greater than 50% of the reference volume. However, after irradiation of volumes smaller than 40%, breathing rate increases were not accompanied by death. A heterogeneous response of the mouse lung to radiation was observed in the first experiment and confirmed by the second experiment. For a given volume irradiated, the isoeffect dose was always less for the base than for the apex of the lung. The threshold volume for breathing rate changes was less than 17 and 40% when the irradiated volumes involved the apex and base, respectively. For lethality, the threshold volume was between 40 and 70% for the base and greater than 50% for the apex of the lung. Finally, damage as assessed by histological evidence of pneumonitis was observed in the irradiated area only.
(a) The volume effect was resolvable in mice, (b) the volume effect in mouse lung exhibits a clear threshold for morbidity, (c) the threshold volume for morbidity is dependent on the end point, (d) the response of mouse lung is heterogeneous, dependent on the site irradiated, and is always greater for the same volumes irradiated in the base than the apex, and, (e) histopathological damage does not always produce observable morbidity.
本研究的目的是:(a)确定小鼠肺脏照射剂量和照射体积与损伤及发病率之间的关系;(b)确定部分肺照射后发病的阈值体积;以及(c)确定小鼠肺对辐射的反应是否与照射区域无关。
本研究使用C3Hf/Kam雌性小鼠。通过两种方法确定要照射的肺部分体积,即称重法和计算机断层扫描(CT)法。进行了两项实验来确定体积效应,并确定小鼠肺对辐射的反应是否均匀。在第一个实验中,对包括肺底部的84%、70%和40%、包括肺尖部的50%、33%和17%、中部的43%以及肺尖部17%与肺底部40%之和的57%等部分体积给予12至20 Gy的单次X射线剂量。在第二个实验中,对肺尖部和底部相同体积的50%以及70 - 75%给予12 - 19.25 Gy的单次剂量照射。通过两个终点指标对放射性肺炎的发病率进行定量,即照射后12至32周的呼吸频率和死亡率。通过肺炎的组织病理学证据评估损伤情况。
在所有照射体积下,呼吸频率和死亡率均获得了明确的剂量反应曲线。在照射后28周,即损伤的肺炎阶段结束时,呼吸频率和死亡率的剂量反应曲线出现明显的体积依赖性偏移,与全肺照射后的这些数据相比,剂量更高。此外,部分肺体积照射的剂量反应曲线斜率比全肺照射后的斜率更平缓。当照射体积等于或大于参考体积的50%时,呼吸频率增加与死亡率相关。然而,在照射小于40%的体积后,呼吸频率增加并未伴随死亡。在第一个实验中观察到小鼠肺对辐射的异质性反应,并在第二个实验中得到证实。对于给定的照射体积,肺底部的等效效应剂量总是低于肺尖部。当照射体积涉及肺尖部和底部时,呼吸频率变化的阈值体积分别小于17%和40%。对于死亡率,肺底部的阈值体积在40%至70%之间,肺尖部大于50%。最后,仅在照射区域观察到通过肺炎组织病理学证据评估的损伤。
(a)小鼠中可分辨出体积效应;(b)小鼠肺中的体积效应表现出明显的发病阈值;(c)发病的阈值体积取决于终点指标;(d)小鼠肺的反应是异质性的,取决于照射部位,并且对于相同照射体积,肺底部的反应总是大于肺尖部;以及(e)组织病理学损伤并不总是导致可观察到的发病率。