Shekelle P G, Markovich M, Louie R
West Los Angeles VAMC, USA.
Med Care. 1995 Aug;33(8):842-50. doi: 10.1097/00005650-199508000-00008.
Back pain is a common illness and chiropractors provide a large proportion of back pain care in the United States. This is the first study to systematically compare chiropractic patients with those who saw other providers for back pain. The authors analyzed data from the RAND Health Insurance Experiment, a community-based study of the use of health services. Insurance claims forms were examined for all visits specified by the patient as occurring for back pain. Visits were grouped into episodes using decision rules and clinical judgment. The primary provider of back pain care was defined as the provider who delivered most of the services. Sociodemographic and health status and attitudes variables of patients were examined for association with the choice of chiropractor. Multivariate logistic regression models were constructed to calculate adjusted odds ratios for independent predictors. There were 1020 episodes of back pain care made by 686 different persons and encompassing 8825 visits. Results indicated that chiropractors were the primary provider for 40% of episodes, and retained as primary provider a greater percentage of their patients (92%) who had a second episode of back pain care than did medical doctors. Health insurance experiment site, white race, male sex, and high school education were independent predictors of choosing a chiropractor. Conclusions suggested that chiropractors were the choice of one third of all patients who sought back pain care, and provided care for 40% of all episodes of care. Geographic site, education, gender, and income were independent patient factors predicting chiropractic use.
背痛是一种常见疾病,在美国,脊椎按摩师提供了很大一部分背痛治疗服务。这是第一项系统比较脊椎按摩治疗患者与因背痛而就诊于其他医疗服务提供者的患者的研究。作者分析了兰德健康保险实验的数据,这是一项基于社区的医疗服务使用情况研究。对患者指定为因背痛而进行的所有就诊的保险理赔表进行了检查。使用决策规则和临床判断将就诊分为不同阶段。背痛治疗的主要提供者被定义为提供大部分服务的提供者。研究了患者的社会人口统计学、健康状况和态度变量与选择脊椎按摩师之间的关联。构建了多变量逻辑回归模型来计算独立预测因素的调整比值比。共有686名不同的人进行了1020次背痛治疗阶段,涵盖8825次就诊。结果表明,脊椎按摩师是40%的治疗阶段的主要提供者,并且在第二次背痛治疗阶段中,与医生相比,脊椎按摩师保留了更高比例(92%)的患者作为主要提供者。健康保险实验地点、白人种族、男性性别和高中学历是选择脊椎按摩师的独立预测因素。研究结论表明,脊椎按摩师是所有寻求背痛治疗的患者中三分之一的选择,并且提供了所有治疗阶段中40%的治疗服务。地理位置、教育程度、性别和收入是预测使用脊椎按摩治疗的独立患者因素。