Priebe S, Gruyters T
Department of Social Psychiatry, Freie Universität Berlin, Germany.
Br J Clin Psychol. 1995 May;34(2):229-36. doi: 10.1111/j.2044-8260.1995.tb01457.x.
This study investigated whether initial reactions, as shown by depressed patients and by the psychiatrist in charge within the first three days of complex hospital treatment, predicted outcome. Sixty-three patients with depressive disorders according to ICD-10 were examined. In addition to basic socio-demographic and clinical data and to baseline symptoms, psychiatrists' optimism, patients' global assessment of treatment and symptom change within the first three days were tested as predictors. The outcome criteria were both observer and self-ratings of symptoms at discharge. Psychiatrists' optimism was the best single predictor of each outcome criterion. Patients' initial subjective reactions predicted self-rated symptoms at discharge. In stepwise multiple regression analyses initial reactions contributed significantly and - in two cases - separately to the overall prediction of outcome. Patients' and psychiatrists' initial reactions in complex hospital treatment of depression are relatively good predictors of outcome and should, therefore, be monitored carefully in research and in clinical practice.
本研究调查了在综合医院治疗的头三天内抑郁症患者及主管精神科医生所表现出的初始反应是否能预测治疗结果。对63例符合ICD - 10标准的抑郁症患者进行了检查。除了基本的社会人口统计学和临床数据以及基线症状外,还测试了精神科医生的乐观态度、患者对治疗的整体评估以及头三天内的症状变化作为预测指标。结果标准为出院时观察者和患者自评的症状。精神科医生的乐观态度是每个结果标准的最佳单一预测指标。患者的初始主观反应可预测出院时的自评症状。在逐步多元回归分析中,初始反应对结果的总体预测有显著贡献,在两个案例中,初始反应分别对结果预测有显著贡献。在抑郁症的综合医院治疗中,患者和精神科医生的初始反应是结果的相对良好预测指标,因此,在研究和临床实践中应仔细监测。