Freed G L, Clark S J, Lohr J A, Sorenson J R
Cecil G. Sheps Center for Health Services Research, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill 27599-7590, USA.
Pediatrics. 1995 Sep;96(3 Pt 1):490-4.
Physician support for breast-feeding mothers has been shown to improve breast-feeding rates, but no evaluation of the adequacy of physicians' breast-feeding-related training has been conducted. This study was designed to assess pediatricians' knowledge, attitudes, training, and activities related to breast-feeding promotion.
Surveys were mailed to a national random sample of pediatric residents (n = 999) and practitioners (n = 610) who were board certified within the previous 3 to 5 years.
Response rates were 74% for residents and 69% for practitioners. Although more than 90% of respondents agreed that pediatricians should be involved in breast-feeding promotion, their clinical knowledge and experience did not suggest a high degree of competency. For example, practitioners were only slightly more aware of breast-feeding's protective effect against otitis media (71% vs 60%), and more than one quarter of both groups did not agree that exclusive breast-feeding is the most beneficial form of infant nutrition. Clinical advice often included inappropriate recommendations for breast-feeding termination or formula supplementation; only 64% of practitioners and 52% of residents knew that supplementing during the first few weeks of life may cause breast-feeding failure. For both groups, prior personal breast-feeding experience (ie, respondent or spouse had breast-fed an infant for 2 or more weeks) was a major determinant of improved clinical knowledge, more frequent activity, and greater self-confidence and perceived effectiveness in the area of breast-feeding promotion. Residents reported that the breast-feeding instruction provided during training was primarily in lecture format, with limited clinical opportunities to practice skills needed to assist breast-feeding mothers. Reflecting on their own training, more than 70% of practitioners recommended that more time be devoted to direct patient interaction and practice of counseling and problem-solving skills.
These results indicate that residency training does not adequately prepare pediatricians for their role in breast-feeding promotion. Improvements in residency training and innovative continuing education programs should be implemented to help pediatricians meet the needs of their breast-feeding patients.
研究表明医生对母乳喂养母亲的支持能够提高母乳喂养率,但尚未对医生与母乳喂养相关培训的充分性进行评估。本研究旨在评估儿科医生关于促进母乳喂养的知识、态度、培训及活动。
向全国范围内过去3至5年获得认证的儿科住院医师(n = 999)和执业医师(n = 610)随机抽样邮寄调查问卷。
住院医师的回复率为74%,执业医师的回复率为69%。尽管超过90%的受访者同意儿科医生应参与促进母乳喂养,但他们的临床知识和经验显示其能力水平不高。例如,执业医师仅略微更了解母乳喂养对中耳炎的预防作用(71%对60%),两组中超过四分之一的人不同意纯母乳喂养是婴儿最有益的营养方式。临床建议中常常包含关于终止母乳喂养或添加配方奶的不当建议;只有64%的执业医师和52%的住院医师知道在生命最初几周添加配方奶可能导致母乳喂养失败。对于两组而言,之前个人的母乳喂养经历(即受访者或其配偶曾母乳喂养婴儿达2周或更长时间)是临床知识提高、活动更频繁、在促进母乳喂养方面自信心更强及自我感觉更有效的主要决定因素。住院医师报告称培训期间提供的母乳喂养指导主要是讲座形式,协助母乳喂养母亲所需技能的临床实践机会有限。超过70%的执业医师在反思自身培训时建议应投入更多时间进行直接的患者互动以及咨询和解决问题技能的实践。
这些结果表明住院医师培训未能使儿科医生充分胜任促进母乳喂养的角色。应改进住院医师培训并实施创新的继续教育项目,以帮助儿科医生满足母乳喂养患者的需求。