Bertschy G
Département Universitaire de Psychiatrie Adulte, Prilly-Lausanne, Switzerland.
Eur Arch Psychiatry Clin Neurosci. 1995;245(2):114-24. doi: 10.1007/BF02190738.
Available data (this review includes old major articles and recent articles) show that, although results are heterogeneous, methadone maintenance treatments (MMTs) have a real efficiency not only to reduce illicit opiate abuse (50-80% of patients under MMT did not use heroin in the preceding month) but also to reduce criminality, HIV risks and mortality, and to improve social rehabilitation, without inducing other alternative substance abuse. A minority of patients (perhaps 5-20%) stay on MMT on a very long-term basis (more than 10 years). Efficiency of MMTs are rather poorly related to patients' variables, with the exception of a moderately deleterious effect of a low age at onset of opiate dependence, a precocious or high involvement in criminality and an abuse of non-opiate drugs. On the other hand, variables related to treatment play a more important role in explaining heterogeneity of results. Optimal daily dose, high quality of medical and psycho-social services, clear orientation towards social rehabilitation and treatment retention (to allow a sufficient duration of treatment) and slow detoxification regimen of well-stabilized patients are all factors contributing to better results.
现有数据(本综述涵盖了早期的主要文章和近期的文章)表明,尽管结果存在异质性,但美沙酮维持治疗(MMT)确实有效,不仅能减少非法阿片类药物滥用(接受MMT治疗的患者中有50%-80%在前一个月未使用海洛因),还能减少犯罪、降低感染艾滋病毒的风险和死亡率,并改善社会康复情况,且不会引发其他替代性药物滥用。少数患者(可能5%-20%)长期接受MMT治疗(超过10年)。MMT的疗效与患者的变量关系不大,不过阿片类药物依赖发病年龄低、过早或高度涉入犯罪以及滥用非阿片类药物有一定的不良影响。另一方面,与治疗相关的变量在解释结果的异质性方面发挥着更重要的作用。最佳日剂量、高质量的医疗和心理社会服务、明确的社会康复导向和治疗保留率(以确保足够的治疗时长)以及病情稳定患者的缓慢戒毒方案都是取得更好疗效的因素。