Barrett B
Eau Claire Family Medicine Residency Program, WI 54701-3832, USA.
Soc Sci Med. 1995 Jun;40(12):1611-21. doi: 10.1016/0277-9536(94)00348-w.
This paper describes contemporary and historical interactions of medical belief and practice among the six ethnic groups of Nicaragua's Atlantic Coast--Mestizo, Creole, Miskitu, Sumu, Garifuna and Rama. The expansion of preventive medicine and primary care under the Sandanista-led government during the 1980s is presented, along with brief descriptions of counter-revolutionary attacks on the health care system. Traditional uses of medicinal plants and various forms of spiritual healing are then juxtaposed with the sporadic introduction of European and North American biomedicine throughout history. Next, the results of a health care survey carried out in 1990 are used to: (1) demonstrate the widespread use of the official health care system; and (2) show that traditional practices--use of herbal medicine, visits to spiritual healers, and home birth--are more prevalent among specific ethnic and socioeconomic strata of Nicaraguan Atlantic Coast society. Finally, I use these descriptions and survey results to argue for an understanding of health care behavior based on personal identity. I argue that a number of identities--ethnic, historical, political, socioeconomic and spatial (village, city, region or nation)--both situate and influence health care behavior, and thus mediate between the psychological and spiritual realms of illness and healing. Each individual chooses, variably and often subconsciously, to identify with any of a number these 'imagined communities' as he or she makes health care choices. These identity-influenced decisions are then manifested as specific health-related behaviors, forming the real-world data on which this argument is premised.
本文描述了尼加拉瓜大西洋沿岸六个族群——梅斯蒂索人、克里奥尔人、米斯基托人、苏穆人、加里富纳人和拉马人——在医学信仰与实践方面的当代及历史互动。文中介绍了20世纪80年代在桑地诺政府领导下预防医学和初级保健的发展情况,还简要描述了反革命势力对医疗体系的攻击。接着,将药用植物的传统用途和各种形式的精神疗法,与历史上欧洲和北美的生物医学的零星引入情况进行了对比。然后,利用1990年进行的一项医疗保健调查结果来:(1)证明官方医疗保健系统的广泛使用;(2)表明传统做法——使用草药、拜访精神治疗师和在家分娩——在尼加拉瓜大西洋沿岸社会的特定族群和社会经济阶层中更为普遍。最后,我利用这些描述和调查结果,主张基于个人身份来理解医疗保健行为。我认为,一些身份——族群、历史、政治、社会经济和空间(村庄、城市、地区或国家)——既定位又影响医疗保健行为,从而在疾病与治愈的心理和精神领域之间起到中介作用。每个人在做出医疗保健选择时,会以不同方式且往往是下意识地选择认同这些“想象的共同体”中的任何一个。这些受身份影响的决定随后表现为特定的与健康相关的行为,构成了本论点所依据的现实世界数据。