Campbell D A, Yellowlees P M, McLennan G, Coates J R, Frith P A, Gluyas P A, Latimer K M, Luke C G, Martin A J, Ruffin R E
Thoracic Medicine Unit, Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Woodville South Australia.
Thorax. 1995 Mar;50(3):254-9. doi: 10.1136/thx.50.3.254.
The associations between psychiatric caseness, denial, and self reported measures of handicap and morbidity due to asthma in patients suffering a near fatal attack of asthma have not been fully explored.
Seventy seven consecutive subjects who presented to Adelaide teaching hospitals with a near fatal attack of asthma were assessed with a validated semi-structured interview following discharge from hospital.
43% of the patients scored > or = 5 on the GHQ-28 questionnaire. There was a positive correlation between GHQ-28 score and limitation to daily activities due to asthma, and between GHQ-28 score and days lost from work, school or usual daily activities, both of which were retained after adjusting for age and sex. Asthma severity did not show a clear association with GHQ-28 score. The asthmatic patients reported high levels of denial, 57% scoring more than 3 out of 5 on the denial scale of the Illness Behaviour Questionnaire. Presentation with a history of progressive respiratory distress was negatively associated with denial score. This persisted after adjustment for age and sex--that is, those with high denial scores were more likely to report presentation as sudden collapse than progressive respiratory distress.
Psychiatric caseness (GHQ score > or = 5) is associated with high levels of morbidity in asthmatic patients who survive a near fatal attack of asthma. High levels of denial in asthmatic subjects may be life threatening. The link between morbidity associated with asthma and psychiatric features, along with other psychosocial issues, warrants further investigation. A broader paradigm than the traditional medical model should be considered when assessing patients with asthma.
在遭受哮喘致死性发作的患者中,精神疾病状态、否认心理与自我报告的哮喘所致残疾及发病情况之间的关联尚未得到充分研究。
连续纳入77例因哮喘致死性发作就诊于阿德莱德教学医院的患者,出院后采用经过验证的半结构式访谈进行评估。
43%的患者在GHQ-28问卷上得分≥5分。GHQ-28得分与哮喘所致日常活动受限之间呈正相关,与工作、学校或日常活动缺勤天数之间也呈正相关,在对年龄和性别进行校正后,这两个相关性仍然存在。哮喘严重程度与GHQ-28得分未显示出明显关联。哮喘患者报告有较高水平的否认心理,57%的患者在疾病行为问卷的否认量表上得分超过5分中的3分。有进行性呼吸窘迫病史的患者与否认得分呈负相关。在对年龄和性别进行校正后,这种相关性仍然存在,即否认得分高的患者比有进行性呼吸窘迫的患者更有可能报告为突然虚脱。
精神疾病状态(GHQ得分≥5分)与哮喘致死性发作存活患者的高发病率相关。哮喘患者的高度否认心理可能危及生命。哮喘相关发病与精神特征以及其他心理社会问题之间的联系值得进一步研究。在评估哮喘患者时,应考虑比传统医学模式更广泛的范例。