Magrath I T, Ziegler J L
Br Med J. 1976 Mar 13;1(6010):615-8. doi: 10.1136/bmj.1.6010.615.
A controlled randomised trial was carried out to evaluate the efficacy of BCG immunotherapy in preventing relapse in patients with Burkitt's lymphoma in whom remission had been induced with cyclophosphamide. Twenty-one patients were treated with BCG, and 19 were controls. Eleven patients in each group relapsed during a follow-up period long enough to make it unlikely that further relapses would occur. There were no significant differences in the length of remission or the site of relapse that could be attributed to treatment. Eleven patients died: of these none of the six patients in the BCG group but all of the five in the control group had stage D lymphomas. BCG treatment increased the rate of recovery from tumour-induced immunosuppression, but within the BCG group immunocompetence improved most rapidly in the patients who relapsed-a finding that appears to contradict the tenet retionalising the use of immunological adjuvants as treatment.
开展了一项对照随机试验,以评估卡介苗免疫疗法对预防接受环磷酰胺诱导缓解的伯基特淋巴瘤患者复发的疗效。21例患者接受卡介苗治疗,19例为对照。每组中有11例患者在随访期间复发,随访时间足够长,以至于不太可能再出现进一步复发。在缓解期长度或复发部位方面,未发现可归因于治疗的显著差异。11例患者死亡:其中卡介苗组的6例患者均未死亡,而对照组的5例患者全部死亡,且均为D期淋巴瘤。卡介苗治疗提高了肿瘤诱导的免疫抑制的恢复率,但在卡介苗组中,复发患者的免疫能力改善最快——这一发现似乎与将免疫佐剂用作治疗的理论原则相矛盾。