Gianni L, Munzone E, Capri G, Villani F, Spreafico C, Tarenzi E, Fulfaro F, Caraceni A, Martini C, Laffranchi A
Division of Medical Oncology, Istituto Nazionale Tumori, Milan, Italy.
J Natl Cancer Inst. 1995 Aug 2;87(15):1169-75. doi: 10.1093/jnci/87.15.1169.
To date, anthracyclines are the most active drugs against breast tumors, and the taxane paclitaxel (Taxol) looks very promising. Both classes of drugs are affected by cellular multidrug-resistance mechanisms, and therefore their sequential use raises the possibility of clinical cross-resistance. It is therefore important to assess the activity of paclitaxel in patients with clinical resistance to anthracyclines.
We assessed the safety and efficacy of paclitaxel administered by the logistically convenient 3-hour infusion to breast cancer patients who had disease progression within 12 months since prior therapy with anthracyclines.
Fifty-one patients with metastatic breast cancer who had all relapsed or whose disease had progressed within 12 months from completion of an anthracycline-containing chemotherapy protocol (six receiving adjuvant therapy, 19 receiving neoadjuvant therapy, and 26 receiving treatment for metastatic disease) were enrolled in this phase II trial from June 1992 to May 1994. After medication to prevent type I acute hypersensitivity reactions, paclitaxel was given intravenously over 3 hours at 175 mg/m2 to the first 15 patients and at 225 mg/m2 to the next 36 patients. The median age was 50 years (range, 31-62 years), and the median Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group performance status was 0 (range, 0-2).
Patients received a median of five cycles (range, one to 11 cycles). After initial doses of 175 and 225 mg/m2, paclitaxel could be increased by 25 mg/m2 in 73% and 58% of cycles, respectively. Among 50 assessable patients, seven achieved a complete response and 12 achieved a partial response (response rate, 38% [95% confidence interval = 25%-53%]). The median duration of response was 7 months (range, 4-16 months), and the median time to disease progression for all patients was 5 months. Grade 4 neutropenia occurred in 3% of the cycles and in 12% of the patients and was never associated with fever and infection. Common toxic effects were myalgia and arthralgia (94% of the patients; 4% grade 3), peripheral neuropathy (92% of the patients; 8% grade 3), and alopecia (all patients). Pruritus and neuropathy were significantly more frequent and severe, respectively, with the higher dose (P < .01 by chi 2 test). Frequency and severity of other toxic effects were similar at either starting dose. Ten patients had symptoms of neuro-optic toxicity. Only one patient had a grade 2 hypersensitivity reaction.
Paclitaxel at starting doses of 175 and 225 mg/m2 given as a 3-hour infusion can safely be administered to, and is active in women whose disease has progressed after prior treatment with anthracyclines. There was evidence of increased toxicity at the higher dose but no suggestion of better efficacy.
Paclitaxel by a 3-hour infusion in combination with doxorubicin should be investigated in patients with metastatic breast cancer. Unless randomized trials demonstrate greater efficacy of the more toxic higher dose, it is suggested that a dose of 175-200 mg/m2 be administered with the 3-hour infusion schedule.
迄今为止,蒽环类药物是对抗乳腺肿瘤最有效的药物,而紫杉烷类的紫杉醇(泰素)看起来也非常有前景。这两类药物都会受到细胞多药耐药机制的影响,因此它们的序贯使用增加了临床交叉耐药的可能性。所以,评估紫杉醇在对蒽环类药物产生临床耐药的患者中的活性非常重要。
我们评估了对自先前接受蒽环类药物治疗后的12个月内疾病进展的乳腺癌患者,采用操作简便的3小时静脉输注方式给予紫杉醇的安全性和疗效。
1992年6月至1994年5月,51例转移性乳腺癌患者被纳入该II期试验,这些患者均在含蒽环类化疗方案完成后的12个月内复发或疾病进展(6例接受辅助治疗,19例接受新辅助治疗,26例接受转移性疾病治疗)。在给予预防I型急性过敏反应的药物后,前15例患者以175mg/m²的剂量静脉输注紫杉醇3小时,后36例患者以225mg/m²的剂量静脉输注紫杉醇3小时。中位年龄为50岁(范围31 - 62岁),东部肿瘤协作组(Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group)的中位体能状态为0(范围0 - 2)。
患者接受的中位周期数为5个周期(范围1 - 11个周期)。在初始剂量为175mg/m²和225mg/m²后,分别有73%和58%的周期中紫杉醇剂量可增加25mg/m²。在50例可评估的患者中,7例达到完全缓解,12例达到部分缓解(缓解率为38%[95%置信区间 = 25% - 53%])。中位缓解持续时间为7个月(范围4 - 16个月),所有患者的疾病进展中位时间为5个月。4级中性粒细胞减少在3%的周期中出现,在12%的患者中出现,且从未与发热和感染相关。常见的毒性反应为肌痛和关节痛(94%的患者;4%为3级)、周围神经病变(92%的患者;8%为3级)以及脱发(所有患者)。瘙痒和神经病变分别在较高剂量组中更频繁且更严重(经卡方检验P <.01)。其他毒性反应的频率和严重程度在两种起始剂量下相似。10例患者有视神经毒性症状。仅1例患者出现2级过敏反应。
起始剂量为175mg/m²和225mg/m²的紫杉醇以3小时静脉输注方式给药,对先前接受蒽环类药物治疗后疾病进展的女性患者来说是安全的且有活性。有证据表明较高剂量下毒性增加,但未显示出更好的疗效。
对于转移性乳腺癌患者,应研究3小时静脉输注紫杉醇联合阿霉素的情况。除非随机试验证明毒性更大的较高剂量有更高的疗效,否则建议采用3小时输注方案给予175 - 200mg/m²的剂量。