Gilbertson M, Kamhi A G
University of Central Arkansas, Conway, USA.
J Speech Hear Res. 1995 Jun;38(3):630-42. doi: 10.1044/jshr.3803.630.
This study examined novel word-learning abilities in young school-age children with mild-to-moderate hearing losses. We questioned whether degree of hearing loss or measures of language and phonological processing abilities were more likely to be related to novel word-learning ability. Subjects were 20 children with hearing impairment (M = 9:0) and 20 children with normal hearing (M = 6:5) matched for receptive vocabulary knowledge. Children were administered measures of language and phonological processing. The novel word-learning task consisted of an acquisition and retention phase in which children received a series of trials to learn to produce four novel words. Half of the children with hearing impairment performed comparably to the children with normal hearing on all of the measures obtained, whereas the the other 10 children with hearing impairment performed more poorly than the higher functioning children with hearing impairment and all of the children with normal hearing on most of the measures of language, phonological processing, and novel word learning. Degree of hearing loss was not related to language or word-learning abilities. These findings suggest that the population of children with mild-to-moderate hearing loss may contain two distinct groups: a group of normally developing children who have a hearing loss and a group of children with language impairment who have a hearing loss. The implications of this categorization will be discussed.
本研究考察了轻度至中度听力损失的学龄儿童的新单词学习能力。我们质疑听力损失程度或语言及语音处理能力的测量指标是否更有可能与新单词学习能力相关。研究对象为20名听力受损儿童(平均年龄9:0)和20名听力正常儿童(平均年龄6:5),两组儿童的接受性词汇知识相匹配。对儿童进行了语言和语音处理方面的测量。新单词学习任务包括一个习得和保留阶段,在此阶段,儿童接受一系列试验以学习说出四个新单词。一半的听力受损儿童在所有获得的测量指标上表现与听力正常儿童相当,而另外10名听力受损儿童在语言、语音处理和新单词学习的大多数测量指标上,比功能较高的听力受损儿童及所有听力正常儿童表现更差。听力损失程度与语言或单词学习能力无关。这些发现表明,轻度至中度听力损失儿童群体可能包含两个不同的组:一组是听力损失但发育正常的儿童,另一组是听力损失且有语言障碍的儿童。将讨论这种分类的意义。