Freese R, Born P, Müller-Isberner R
Klinik für gerichtliche Psychiatrie, Haina.
Nervenarzt. 1995 Jul;66(7):542-9.
The analysis of 11 cases of violent offenses committed during hospital order treatment in the Haina Forensic Psychiatric Hospital between 1985 and 1991 showed that biographical and forensic variables are more powerful predictors of dangerousness than treatment and psychopathological data. In more than half of these cases it was at least questionable whether the individuals had been placed correctly inside the hospital order system. In comparison to data found in inmate populations and a new study from North America the question arises as to whether the treatment might not have contributed to increase dangerousness in at least some of our cases.
对1985年至1991年间在海纳法医精神病医院接受住院强制治疗期间发生的11起暴力犯罪案件的分析表明,个人经历和法医变量比治疗及精神病理学数据更能有力地预测危险性。在超过半数的这些案件中,这些人是否被正确纳入住院强制治疗系统至少是有疑问的。与在囚犯群体中发现的数据以及北美一项新研究相比,问题在于我们的至少部分案例中,治疗是否可能反而增加了危险性。