Spittler J F
Neurologische Universitätsklinik, Knappschaftskrankenhaus Bochum-Langendreer.
Schweiz Arch Neurol Psychiatr (1985). 1993;144(2):101-11.
Following the Central European tradition of the triad system of psychiatry of Kurt Schneider (I. Abnormal Reactions/Personalities, II. Acute/Chronic Organic Psychosis, III. Schizophrenia/Cyclothymia) (19) a series of 210 cases of acute organic psychoses was collected. In contrast to DSM-III and in accord with W.A. Lishman (10), this series comprises not only delirium, but the entire range of impairments of consciousness from the "Durchgangssyndrom" of H.H. Wieck (24) to clouding of consciousness and coma, twilight states or apallic syndromes. From this series we present some elementary quantitative data concerning the age distribution of different etiologies, that are generally considered helpful in the diagnostic process. In contrast to this opinion, a single case of bromazepam-induced delirium shows: The anamnesis may be misleading, the general and neurological examination as well as the radiological, laboratory and electrophysiological tests could be insignificant. The essential diagnostic tool is the descriptive or phenomenological psychopathological observation. Compared to it, the general data of the age distribution of different etiologies of organic psychoses are of comparably little help in making a diagnosis. Artificial intelligence and medical expert systems are set out to replace the diagnosis of the physician. Eliminative materialistic neuroscience is set out to replace old-fashioned descriptive psychopathology by quantitative electrical and chemical data. Through the method of systematically confronting general quantitative data with suitably chosen single cases it should be possible to find out essential differences between general reductionist statements and the properties of complex qualitative phenomena like the individual human mind.
遵循库尔特·施耐德精神病学三元系统的中欧传统(一、异常反应/人格,二、急性/慢性器质性精神病,三、精神分裂症/环性心境障碍)(19),收集了一系列210例急性器质性精神病病例。与《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第三版不同,且与W.A.利什曼的观点一致(10),该系列不仅包括谵妄,还涵盖了从H.H.维克的“一过性综合征”(24)到意识模糊、昏迷、朦胧状态或去皮层综合征等整个意识障碍范围。从这个系列中,我们给出了一些关于不同病因年龄分布的基本定量数据,这些数据通常被认为在诊断过程中是有帮助的。与这种观点相反,一例溴西泮诱发的谵妄病例显示:病史可能具有误导性,全身和神经系统检查以及放射学、实验室和电生理检查可能无足轻重。关键的诊断工具是描述性或现象学的精神病理学观察。与之相比,器质性精神病不同病因的年龄分布一般数据在做出诊断方面帮助相对较小。人工智能和医学专家系统旨在取代医生的诊断。排除性唯物主义神经科学旨在用定量的电学和化学数据取代老式的描述性精神病理学。通过将一般定量数据与适当选择的单个病例进行系统对比的方法,应该有可能找出一般还原论陈述与像个体人类思维这样的复杂定性现象的属性之间的本质差异。