Laubichler W, Kühberger A, Sedlmeier P
Institut für Gerichtliche Medizin, Universität Salzburg.
Arch Kriminol. 1995 Jan-Feb;195(1-2):9-17.
In the course of 25 years we examined 103 arsonists psychiatrically. In 10 of these cases the firesetting was accompanied by a suicidal attempt, or was inspired by a suicidal motive. These arsonists differ from arsonists with other motives: typically suicidal arsonists are older, have a higher share of women, higher values of psychosocial burden, and different psychiatric diagnoses. Moreover, the fire ist set mainly in the own flat, revenge is seen much more frequently as an accompanying motive, and, typically, suicidally motivated arsonists do set only one single fire. Out of our 10 arsonists, 5 originally had intended to die in the flames but then ran away exasperated or were saved; this combination is termed "self-immolation" in older papers. We suggest the term "suicide in combination with firesetting" for cases, where, after having set a fire, the arsonist tries to commit suicide at a different place and with other means than fire. In 7 cases we found the motive of extended suicide, with taking along the own property; in 2 cases, along with the suicide, also intimates were intended to put to dead. One female arsonist was saved out of the fire and then, after being discharged from the hospital, tried to kill her unfaithful friend. About one half of the suicidally motivated firesetters was alcoholized at the time of their firesetting while 70% of the arsonists with other motives were alcoholized, 4 of the suicidal arsonists were alcoholics altogether, similar to the whole group of arsonists, from which, approximately, one half are alcoholics.
在25年的时间里,我们对103名纵火犯进行了精神病学检查。在其中10个案例中,纵火行为伴有自杀企图,或受自杀动机驱使。这些纵火犯与其他动机的纵火犯不同:典型的自杀性纵火犯年龄较大,女性比例较高,心理社会负担值较高,且有不同的精神科诊断。此外,火灾主要发生在自己的公寓内,报复作为伴随动机更为常见,而且,典型的受自杀动机驱使的纵火犯通常只放一次火。在我们的10名纵火犯中,有5人最初打算葬身火海,但随后愤怒地逃离或被救;在旧文献中,这种情况被称为“自焚”。对于纵火犯在放火后试图在不同地点、用除火以外的其他方式自杀的案例,我们建议使用“与纵火相结合的自杀”这一术语。在7个案例中,我们发现了扩大自杀的动机,还包括拿走自己的财产;在2个案例中,除了自杀,还打算杀死亲密的人。一名女性纵火犯从火灾中获救,出院后试图杀死她不忠的朋友。约一半有自杀动机的纵火犯在纵火时处于醉酒状态,而有其他动机的纵火犯中70%处于醉酒状态,4名自杀性纵火犯中有酗酒者,这与整个纵火犯群体情况相似,纵火犯群体中约一半是酗酒者。