Chen J, Godschalk M F, Katz P G, Mulligan T
Division of Urology, Hunter Holmes McGuire Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Richmond, Virginia, USA.
J Urol. 1995 May;153(5):1476-7.
We studied the effect of combining intracavernous injection and an external vacuum in 10 men with erectile dysfunction who previously failed attempts at treatment with either method as single therapy. We measured the length, circumference and buckling pressure of the penis at baseline, after applying negative pressure (250 mm. Hg for 2 minutes), 15 minutes after intracavernous injection of 60 mg. papaverine or 30 micrograms prostaglandin E1 and after combining both modalities. No patient achieved adequate rigidity (defined as a penile buckle pressure greater than 450 gm.) with single therapy. The mean buckle pressure using vacuum alone was 125.0 +/- 53.6 gm. After intracavernous injection the mean buckle pressure was 117.0 +/- 38.3 gm. In contrast, all 10 subjects responded to combination therapy with a mean buckle pressure of 565.0 +/- 56.8 gm. (p < 0.0001). After 10 months of followup 3 subjects were still using the combination and were satisfied with the erectile response, 1 found that he no longer needed the addition of external vacuum after using combination therapy for 3 months, 1 used the combination for 9 months and then stopped because of an intervening acute illness, 1 lost the partner due to death, 2 found combination therapy to be too cumbersome and 2 were lost to followup. We conclude that external vacuum devices can augment a partial response to intracavernous injection and the combination may be an alternative treatment before intrapenile prosthesis implantation.
我们对10名勃起功能障碍男性患者进行了研究,这些患者此前单独使用海绵体内注射或外部真空疗法均治疗失败,此次研究联合使用这两种方法的效果。我们在基线时、施加负压(250毫米汞柱,持续2分钟)后、海绵体内注射60毫克罂粟碱或30微克前列腺素E1后15分钟以及联合使用两种方法后,测量阴茎的长度、周长和弯曲压力。单独使用单一疗法时,没有患者达到足够的硬度(定义为阴茎弯曲压力大于450克)。单独使用真空时,平均弯曲压力为125.0±53.6克。海绵体内注射后,平均弯曲压力为117.0±38.3克。相比之下,所有10名受试者对联合疗法均有反应,平均弯曲压力为565.0±56.8克(p<0.0001)。随访10个月后,3名受试者仍在使用联合疗法,对勃起反应满意;1名受试者在使用联合疗法3个月后发现不再需要额外的外部真空;1名受试者使用联合疗法9个月后因急性疾病而停止;1名受试者因伴侣死亡而停止;2名受试者认为联合疗法过于繁琐;2名受试者失访。我们得出结论,外部真空装置可增强海绵体内注射的部分反应,在阴茎假体植入前,联合疗法可能是一种替代治疗方法。