Tharp M E, Shidnia H
Indiana Regional Cancer Center, Indianapolis 46219, USA.
Laryngoscope. 1995 Apr;105(4 Pt 1):391-6. doi: 10.1288/00005537-199504000-00011.
Because of reports of anaplastic transformation following irradiation, this study examines the incidence of anaplastic transformation and local control of these lesions. This review of seven patients who had verrucous carcinoma of the head and neck that was treated with irradiation shows local control in 71% of cases. There were no cases of anaplastic transformation. This report adds to the literature two cases of "de-differentiation" to less differentiated squamous carcinomas; one such case occurred after surgery alone. The literature is reviewed. Overall, anaplastic transformation is reported in 7% of patients who had irradiation. De-differentiation occurs after surgery as well. The rate of local control with irradiation is less than 50%; with surgery it is 85%. It is concluded that surgery should be used if the procedure has acceptable morbidity. Otherwise, irradiation can be used. Failures can be salvaged surgically. "Anaplastic transformation" should not affect treatment approach.
由于有关于放疗后间变转化的报道,本研究调查了间变转化的发生率以及这些病变的局部控制情况。这项对7例接受放疗的头颈部疣状癌患者的回顾性研究显示,71%的病例实现了局部控制。没有间变转化的病例。本报告补充了两例“去分化”为低分化鳞状癌的病例;其中一例仅在手术后发生。对相关文献进行了综述。总体而言,据报道7%接受放疗的患者发生了间变转化。去分化也发生在手术后。放疗的局部控制率低于50%;手术的局部控制率为85%。得出的结论是,如果手术的发病率可接受,则应采用手术治疗。否则,可以使用放疗。失败的病例可以通过手术挽救。“间变转化”不应影响治疗方法。