Mani R, Regan F, Sheridan J, Batty V
Department of Medical Physics, University of Southampton Hospitals, United Kingdom.
Dermatol Surg. 1995 Apr;21(4):324-6. doi: 10.1111/j.1524-4725.1995.tb00182.x.
Traditionally, venography is used to investigate deep vein thrombosis (DVT), though duplex ultrasound offers a challenging, noninvasive alternative method and previous reports have described the use of duplex ultrasound for detecting proximal lesions.
To compare duplex ultrasound imaging with venography for both proximal and distal lesions using the probe compression technique and a different protocol.
Duplex scans were done by the same operator prior and blind to venography, which was performed using a standard protocol with the films being reviewed blindly by a second radiologist at a later date.
In 74 patients, 21 of 22 above-knee lesions present on venography were detected by duplex scanning and there was complete agreement in the 52 of 52 venogram negatives. For lesions below the knee, duplex detected 26 of 27 lesions also present on venography and agreed on 37 of 43 venogram negatives. These figures give duplex ultrasound overall accuracies of 99% and 90% (Kappa 98% and 89%) for above- and below-knee lesions, respectively.
These figures suggest duplex ultrasound technique compares favorably with venography for diagnosing both proximal and distal lesions.
传统上,静脉造影用于研究深静脉血栓形成(DVT),尽管双功超声提供了一种具有挑战性的非侵入性替代方法,且先前的报告描述了使用双功超声检测近端病变。
使用探头压迫技术和不同方案,比较双功超声成像与静脉造影对近端和远端病变的诊断效果。
双功扫描由同一名操作人员在静脉造影之前进行,且操作人员对静脉造影情况不知情,静脉造影采用标准方案进行,胶片随后由另一位放射科医生进行盲法阅片。
在74例患者中,静脉造影显示的22例膝上病变中有21例通过双功扫描检测到,52例静脉造影阴性者结果完全一致。对于膝下病变,双功超声检测到静脉造影显示的27例病变中的26例,43例静脉造影阴性者中有37例结果一致。这些数据表明,双功超声对膝上和膝下病变的总体准确率分别为99%和90%(Kappa值分别为98%和89%)。
这些数据表明,双功超声技术在诊断近端和远端病变方面与静脉造影相比具有优势。