Sim J
Nurs Ethics. 1995 Mar;2(1):31-40. doi: 10.1177/096973309500200105.
This paper explores the nature of rights, and their implications for the ethics of nursing. A right is seen as an entitlement which is justified on moral and/or legal grounds, and which may take the form of a right of action or a right of recipience, or both; in either case, correlative duties are generally imposed on others. Some of the conflicts which can occur among two or more conflicting rights are examined through three hypothetical scenarios, and approaches to their resolution are suggested. The question of whether nurses, as nurses, possess rights is then considered, and it is suggested that they do not. In conclusion, it is argued that, if rights are to be a helpful concept, they must be carefully defined and analysed, and their relationship to one another, and to duties, must be clarified.
本文探讨了权利的本质及其对护理伦理的影响。权利被视为一种基于道德和/或法律依据而合理存在的权益,它可以采取行动权或接受权的形式,或者两者兼具;在任何一种情况下,通常都会对他人施加相应的义务。通过三个假设情景,研究了两种或更多相互冲突的权利之间可能出现的一些冲突,并提出了解决这些冲突的方法。接着探讨了护士作为护士是否拥有权利的问题,并认为他们并不拥有。总之,本文认为,如果权利要成为一个有用的概念,就必须对其进行仔细的定义和分析,并且必须阐明它们彼此之间以及与义务的关系。