Hatfield P, Beevers D G
University Department of Medicine, City Hospital, Birmingham, UK.
J Hum Hypertens. 1995 Jan;9(1):31-6.
There are now at least nine medical journals which are exclusively related to the topic of hypertension, of which two started publication in 1992. We have conducted an analysis of the impact of these journals in the published body of medical research into hypertension as well as the reports published in 1993 by the hypertension management 'guidelines' committees in the UK, USA, New Zealand, Canada and the WHO. Finally an analysis was conducted of the contents of the four established hypertension journals (Hypertension, Journal of Hypertension, Journal of Human Hypertension and American Journal of Hypertension) in 1992 in relation to the country of origin of the papers and the topics covered. Only 19% of all the hypertension papers listed in Index Medicus in 1992 were from the four established journals and only 12.6% of papers quoted in the 'guidelines' reports were from these journals. Most papers, and particularly the important ones, tend to be published in the weekly or monthly general medical journals. In the contents of the four journals, Hypertension and Journal of Hypertension tended to take more papers devoted to basic science than the Journal of Human Hypertension and American Journal of Hypertension which favoured more clinically relevant papers. American papers tended to go to American journals while European and Japanese papers appeared in all journals, although the Japanese bias towards basic science meant that their contributions also appeared in the two basic science orientated journals.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
目前至少有9种医学期刊专门涉及高血压主题,其中两种于1992年创刊。我们分析了这些期刊在已发表的高血压医学研究文献中的影响力,以及英国、美国、新西兰、加拿大和世界卫生组织的高血压管理“指南”委员会在1993年发表的报告。最后,对1992年四种老牌高血压期刊(《高血压》《高血压杂志》《人类高血压杂志》和《美国高血压杂志》)的内容进行了分析,涉及论文的原产国和涵盖的主题。1992年《医学索引》列出的所有高血压论文中,只有19%来自这四种老牌期刊,“指南”报告引用的论文中只有12.6%来自这些期刊。大多数论文,尤其是重要论文,往往发表在周刊或月刊的综合医学期刊上。在这四种期刊的内容中,《高血压》和《高血压杂志》倾向于收录更多关于基础科学的论文,而《人类高血压杂志》和《美国高血压杂志》则更青睐临床相关论文。美国的论文倾向于发表在美国期刊上,而欧洲和日本的论文则出现在所有期刊上,不过日本对基础科学的偏好意味着他们的论文也会出现在两种以基础科学为导向的期刊上。(摘要截选至250词)