Runkel M, Blum J, Röder W, Ahlers J, Kreitner K F
Klinik und Poliklinik für Unfallchirurgie, Johannes-Gutenberg-Universität Mainz.
Aktuelle Traumatol. 1993 Oct;23(6):297-301.
A radiologic Lachman test of both knees was performed in 35 patients with surgically verified tears of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL). We found a mean anterior drawer of 3.2 mm for uninjured joints, 4.5 mm for isolated ACL-tears and 10.8 mm for complex ACL-injuries. Sensitivity of the radiological Lachman test was 95% for complex ACL-injuries as only 23% in case of isolated ACL-ruptures. Failure of diagnosis due to clinical investigation in case of ACL-ruptures could not be proved by means of radiological Lachman-test. Technical requirements and radiation exposure are further disadvantages. Clinically doubtful cases of acute knee injuries should therefore be investigated with other diagnostic procedures.
对35例经手术证实为前交叉韧带(ACL)撕裂的患者进行了双膝的放射学拉赫曼试验。我们发现,未受伤关节的平均前抽屉距离为3.2毫米,单纯ACL撕裂为4.5毫米,复杂ACL损伤为10.8毫米。放射学拉赫曼试验对复杂ACL损伤的敏感度为95%,而在单纯ACL断裂时仅为23%。放射学拉赫曼试验无法证实ACL断裂时临床检查存在的诊断失误情况。技术要求和辐射暴露是另外的不利因素。因此,临床上对急性膝关节损伤存疑的病例应采用其他诊断方法进行检查。