Leigh J P
Department of Economics, San Jose State University, CA 95192-0114, USA.
Alcohol Alcohol. 1995 Jan;30(1):71-86.
Samples of employed persons within the US were drawn from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey II (n = 8477), and the Quality of Employment Survey (n = 1393) to test the hypothesis that a positive association existed between alcohol use and job hazards. Heavy total alcohol use, or beer or wine or liquor use separately, were the dependent variables. The key independent variables included subjects' evaluations of hazardous nature of the job and fatality rates within occupations and industries. Models were estimated with logistic regressions controlling for age, gender, race and other covariates. Only one robust finding emerged: heavy beer use was found to be positively and strongly correlated with the fatality rate within occupations. Additional correlations between job hazards and heavy alcohol use were weak, generated large P values, and some suggested an inverse association. The lack of robust findings for the additional correlations may partially be explained by the associations between job categories on the one hand and choice of beverage on the other. Blue-collar jobs are more hazardous than white-collar jobs, on average. Persons in blue-collar jobs were more likely to drink beer, while those in white-collar jobs were more likely to drink wine or liquor (spirits). Separate analyses of beer, wine and liquor appeared essential to explaining correlations between dangerous jobs and heavy alcohol use in these data. Limitations of the study included (1) age of the data (from the 1970s). (2) alcohol use and some job hazards were measured by self-report, and (3) data were from only one country.
美国就业人员样本取自第二次全国健康与营养检查调查(n = 8477)以及就业质量调查(n = 1393),以检验酒精使用与工作危险之间存在正相关这一假设。总酒精使用量较大,或分别为啤酒、葡萄酒或烈酒的使用量,为因变量。关键自变量包括受试者对工作危险性质的评估以及职业和行业内的死亡率。使用逻辑回归模型进行估计,并控制年龄、性别、种族和其他协变量。仅出现了一个有力的发现:发现大量饮用啤酒与职业死亡率呈正相关且相关性很强。工作危险与大量饮酒之间的其他相关性较弱,P值较大,有些甚至表明存在负相关。其他相关性缺乏有力发现可能部分是由于一方面工作类别与另一方面饮料选择之间的关联。平均而言,蓝领工作比白领工作更危险。从事蓝领工作的人更有可能喝啤酒,而从事白领工作的人更有可能喝葡萄酒或烈酒(烈性酒)。对啤酒、葡萄酒和烈酒进行单独分析对于解释这些数据中危险工作与大量饮酒之间的相关性似乎至关重要。该研究的局限性包括:(1)数据的年代(来自20世纪70年代);(2)酒精使用和一些工作危险通过自我报告来衡量;以及(3)数据仅来自一个国家。