Gordinier M E, Granai C O, Jackson N D, Metheny W P
Women & Infants Hospital, Brown University School of Medicine, Providence, Rhode Island, USA.
Obstet Gynecol. 1995 Jul;86(1):137-9. doi: 10.1016/0029-7844(95)00076-4.
To determine whether a course in cadaver dissection can significantly increase resident knowledge of pelvic anatomy beyond that of current educational practices.
Thirteen first- and second-year residents were randomly assigned to a cadaver dissection course (seven) or a control group (six). The dissection group performed dissections with instruction, using a dissection guide designed specifically for the course. The control group received study references on pelvic anatomy and protected study time. Each participant took a practical and written examination at the beginning and end of the study.
The two groups did not differ statistically in their scores on the pre-test. Both groups improved on the post-test, but the dissection group scored nearly 50% higher on the test than did the controls. The two groups differed significantly on the post-test, adjusted for pre-test performance (P < .01). In their evaluation of the course, participants from the dissection group emphasized its educational value and urged that it be offered to residents as a regular part of their training.
Dissection of a human cadaver provides a valuable experience, allowing participants to gain a greater understanding of surgical anatomy and surgical procedures in a no-risk, unhurried setting. Residents who participated in a cadaver dissection course designed specifically for their needs showed a statistically significant increase in knowledge compared with those without this experience. Both objectively and subjectively, a cadaver dissection course is an excellent tool for instructing gynecology residents.
确定尸体解剖课程是否能显著增加住院医师对盆腔解剖学的了解,使其超出当前教育实践的水平。
13名一年级和二年级住院医师被随机分配到尸体解剖课程组(7人)或对照组(6人)。解剖组在指导下进行解剖,使用专门为该课程设计的解剖指南。对照组收到关于盆腔解剖学的学习参考资料和受保护的学习时间。每位参与者在研究开始和结束时都进行了实践和书面考试。
两组在预测试中的分数没有统计学差异。两组在测试后都有所提高,但解剖组在测试中的得分比对照组高出近50%。在根据预测试表现进行调整后,两组在测试后的差异显著(P < 0.01)。在对课程的评价中,解剖组的参与者强调了其教育价值,并敦促将其作为住院医师培训的常规组成部分提供给他们。
人体尸体解剖提供了宝贵的经验,使参与者能够在无风险、从容的环境中更好地理解手术解剖学和手术操作。与没有这种经验的住院医师相比,参加专门为其需求设计的尸体解剖课程的住院医师在知识方面有统计学上的显著增加。无论从客观还是主观角度来看,尸体解剖课程都是指导妇科住院医师的优秀工具。