Pinnock C B, Roxby D J, Ross J M, Pozza C H, Marshall V R
Division of Surgery, Repatriation General Hospital Daw Park, South Australia.
Br J Urol. 1995 Apr;75(4):461-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1464-410x.1995.tb07266.x.
To study the effectiveness of combining DNA ploidy and the blood-group related membrane antigen Tn as bladder tumour markers which have been individually associated with high tumour grade and poor prognosis. In particular to (i) determine whether use of these two markers would improve tumour detection compared with either alone, particularly of high grade disease and (ii) determine whether intermediate rates of marker expression would occur in bladder cancer patients with no current tumour compared with those with a tumour and a control group with benign prostatic hypertrophy.
A total of 102 patients undergoing cystoscopic monitoring for either benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) or for transitional cell carcinoma (TCC) at the Repatriation Hospital and Flinders Medical Centre were included in the study. The patients comprised three study groups, those with BPH (n = 37), with TCC but no tumour present (n = 38) and those with TCC and a tumour present at cystoscopy (n = 27). Exfoliated cells obtained from bladder washings at cystoscopy were double-labelled using a monoclonal antibody to the Tn antigen and a DNA stain, propidium iodide and examined by flow cytometry.
Rates of marker expression in 27 patients with tumours were 30% for Tn antigen, 30% for aneuploidy and 48% for either marker. Marker expression was strongly associated with tumour grade, with no expression at grade 1, 38% (3/8) tumours at grade 2 and 90% (9/10) at grade 3. In patients with a history of bladder tumours but no current tumour, rates were intermediate (30%) compared with patients with current transitional cell carcinoma (42%) and control patients (19%).
The use of Tn antigen combined with DNA flow cytometry can increase tumour detection, particularly of high grade, aggressive disease. Gradation of expression of these markers across patient groups at increasing risk of a tumour, with intermediate expression in patients with no current tumour, suggests that marker expression may be detecting a preneoplastic stage of the disease, which is not possible with cytology. Given two parallel disease processes for superficial papillary and for high grade disease with invasive potential, the expression of high grade tumour markers in cells from cystoscopically normal bladders may represent a pre-clinical stage of aggressive disease. The identification of patients at risk of invasive disease using combinations of tumour markers may offer advantages in clinical management, particularly when no tumour is present and therefore no histopathological assessment is made.
研究将DNA倍体与血型相关膜抗原Tn联合作为膀胱肿瘤标志物的有效性,这两种标志物单独使用时均与肿瘤高分级及预后不良相关。具体而言,一是确定与单独使用这两种标志物相比,联合使用是否能提高肿瘤检测率,尤其是对高分级疾病的检测率;二是确定与有肿瘤的膀胱癌患者及良性前列腺增生对照组相比,目前无肿瘤的膀胱癌患者中标志物表达率是否处于中间水平。
共有102例在遣返医院和弗林德斯医疗中心因良性前列腺增生(BPH)或移行细胞癌(TCC)接受膀胱镜监测的患者纳入本研究。患者分为三个研究组,分别为BPH患者(n = 37)、有TCC但目前无肿瘤的患者(n = 38)以及有TCC且膀胱镜检查时有肿瘤的患者(n = 27)。膀胱镜检查时从膀胱冲洗液中获取的脱落细胞,使用抗Tn抗原单克隆抗体和DNA染色剂碘化丙啶进行双重标记,并通过流式细胞术检测。
27例有肿瘤患者的标志物表达率为:Tn抗原30%,非整倍体30%,任一标志物表达48%。标志物表达与肿瘤分级密切相关,1级无表达,2级肿瘤表达率为38%(3/8),3级为90%(9/10)。有膀胱肿瘤病史但目前无肿瘤的患者,其表达率(30%)处于有目前移行细胞癌患者(42%)和对照患者(19%)之间。
联合使用Tn抗原与DNA流式细胞术可提高肿瘤检测率,尤其是对高分级、侵袭性疾病的检测。这些标志物在肿瘤发生风险递增的患者组中的表达呈梯度变化,目前无肿瘤的患者表达率处于中间水平,这表明标志物表达可能检测到了疾病的癌前阶段,而细胞学检查无法做到这一点。鉴于浅表乳头状肿瘤和具有侵袭潜能的高分级肿瘤存在两个平行的疾病进程,膀胱镜检查正常的膀胱细胞中高分级肿瘤标志物的表达可能代表侵袭性疾病的临床前期阶段。使用肿瘤标志物组合识别有侵袭性疾病风险的患者可能在临床管理中具有优势,尤其是在无肿瘤且因此未进行组织病理学评估的情况下。