Kline S E, Hedemark L L, Davies S F
Department of Medicine, Hennepin County Medical Center, Minneapolis, MN, USA.
N Engl J Med. 1995 Jul 27;333(4):222-7. doi: 10.1056/NEJM199507273330404.
Outbreaks of tuberculosis have been reported in prisons, nursing homes, urban homeless shelters, and other crowded settings. We report a nonresidential outbreak of tuberculosis that originated in a neighborhood bar.
A homeless patient with highly infectious pulmonary tuberculosis was a regular patron of a neighborhood bar during a long symptomatic interval before diagnosis. We investigated 97 other regular customers and employees of the bar through interviews, tuberculin skin testing, and chest roentgenography. We performed DNA fingerprinting on isolates from the index patient and 11 other patients.
The index patient apparently infected 41 of 97 contacts (42 percent), resulting in 14 cases of active tuberculosis and 27 cases of infection but no disease (indicated by positive tuberculin skin tests). Four other cases of active tuberculosis occurred among regular customers of the bar who were missed by the contact investigation. There were also two secondary cases. Radiographic findings in active cases included upper-lobe disease in seven cases (three cavitary) and negative chest films at the time of diagnosis in four cases. All 12 culture isolates we tested had the same chromosomal-DNA restriction pattern.
The spread of tuberculosis in a neighborhood bar can be a major public health problem. The high rate of infection and disease among the contacts was unexpected and was not due to coinfection with the human immunodeficiency virus. Possible explanations include heavy alcohol use among the contacts, high infectivity of the index case, or both. Sputum cultures must be performed in tuberculin-positive contacts who have symptoms, even if the chest films are normal.
监狱、疗养院、城市无家可归者收容所及其他人员密集场所已报告有结核病暴发。我们报告了一起起源于社区酒吧的非居住场所结核病暴发事件。
一名患有具有高度传染性肺结核的无家可归患者,在诊断前很长一段有症状期内是社区酒吧的常客。我们通过访谈、结核菌素皮肤试验和胸部X线摄影对该酒吧的其他97名常客和员工进行了调查。我们对索引患者及其他11名患者的分离株进行了DNA指纹分析。
索引患者显然感染了97名接触者中的41名(42%),导致14例活动性结核病和27例感染但无疾病(通过结核菌素皮肤试验阳性表明)。在接触者调查遗漏的酒吧常客中又出现了另外4例活动性结核病病例。还有2例二代病例。活动性病例的影像学表现包括7例上叶病变(3例有空洞),4例在诊断时胸部X线片阴性。我们检测的所有12株培养分离株具有相同的染色体DNA限制性图谱。
社区酒吧内结核病传播可能是一个重大的公共卫生问题。接触者中感染和发病的高比率出乎意料,且并非由于与人类免疫缺陷病毒合并感染所致。可能的解释包括接触者大量饮酒、索引病例的高传染性或两者皆有。对有症状的结核菌素阳性接触者即使胸部X线片正常也必须进行痰培养。