Eisenberg E, Carr D B, Chalmers T C
Department of Neurology, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston.
Anesth Analg. 1995 Feb;80(2):290-5. doi: 10.1097/00000539-199502000-00015.
We performed a meta-analysis of the efficacy and safety of neurolytic celiac plexus block (NCPB) for cancer pain. A literature search yielded 59 papers, but data on NCPB in two or more patients was available in only 24 papers. Twenty-one studies were retrospective, one was prospective, and two were randomized and controlled. Cancer type was stated in 1117 of 1145 patients reported (63% pancreatic, 37% nonpancreatic). A bilateral posterior approach with 15-50 mL [corrected] of 50%-100% alcohol was the most common technique. Nonradiologically guided NCPB was performed in 246 patients (32%); guidance was by computed tomography (CT) in 214 (28%), radiograph in 271 (34%), fluoroscopy in 36 (5%), or ultrasound in 7 (< 1%). Good to excellent pain relief was reported in 878/989 patients (89%) during the first 2 wk after NCPB. Long-term followup beyond 3 mo revealed persistent benefit. Partial to complete pain relief continued in approximately 90% of patients alive at 3 mo post-NCPB and in 70%-90% until death even if beyond 3 mo post-NCPB. Patients with pancreatic cancer responded similarly to those with other intraabdominal malignancies. Common adverse effects were transient, including local pain (96%), diarrhea (44%), and hypotension (38%); complications occurred in 2%. This analysis suggests that: 1) NCPB has long-lasting benefit for 70%-90% of patients with pancreatic and other intraabdominal cancers, regardless of the technique used; 2) adverse effects are common but transient and mild; and 3) severe adverse effects are uncommon.
我们对腹腔神经丛毁损性阻滞(NCPB)治疗癌痛的疗效和安全性进行了一项荟萃分析。文献检索得到59篇论文,但只有24篇论文提供了两名或更多患者的NCPB数据。21项研究为回顾性研究,1项为前瞻性研究,2项为随机对照研究。在报告的1145例患者中的1117例(63%为胰腺癌,37%为非胰腺癌)中说明了癌症类型。最常用的技术是采用双侧后路,注入15 - 50毫升[校正后]50% - 100%的酒精。246例患者(32%)采用非放射学引导的NCPB;214例(28%)采用计算机断层扫描(CT)引导,271例(34%)采用X线透视引导,36例(5%)采用荧光镜检查引导,7例(<1%)采用超声引导。在NCPB后的前2周内,878/989例患者(89%)报告疼痛缓解良好至极佳。超过3个月的长期随访显示持续有益。在NCPB后3个月仍存活的患者中,约90%持续部分至完全缓解疼痛,直至死亡时仍有70% - 90%的患者疼痛缓解,即使超过NCPB后3个月。胰腺癌患者与其他腹腔内恶性肿瘤患者的反应相似。常见的不良反应是短暂的,包括局部疼痛(96%)、腹泻(44%)和低血压(38%);并发症发生率为2%。该分析表明:1)无论采用何种技术,NCPB对70% - 90%的胰腺癌和其他腹腔内癌症患者具有长期益处;2)不良反应常见但短暂且轻微;3)严重不良反应不常见。