Dick J C, Jones M P, Zdeblick T A, Kunz D N, Horton W C
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Hennepin County Medical Center, Minneapolis, MN 55415.
J Spinal Disord. 1994 Oct;7(5):402-7.
In lumbar fusion, controversy remains regarding the effectiveness of cross-linking and the necessity of placing pedicle screws at the intermediate levels of the segment to be fused. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the stiffness of various rod/screw constructs used to instrument a three-level fusion with specific emphasis on the effect of cross-linking and the intermediate pedicle screws. Nine lumbar calf spines were mounted at L1 and L5. Pedicle screws (TSRH, Danek, Memphis, TN) were then placed bilaterally in the L2, L3, and L4 pedicles. Random sequence testing of the following constructs was then conducted: TSRH rods connected bilaterally to the L2 and L4 pedicles with and without a cross-link, and rods connected bilaterally at the L2, L3, and L4 levels with and without a cross-link. The tests were conducted on a modified MTS testing machine (MTS, Minneapolis, MN) and consisted of cyclic application of axial load, torsion, and flexion and extension. The tests yielded axial, sagittal, and torsional stiffness values. Statistical analysis was performed using log transformation and Fischer's test of least significant difference. In axial testing the use of additional screws in the intermediate pedicles increased stiffness an average of 160% (p = .007). The addition of a cross-link did not increase stiffness with axial loading. In flexion testing the six-screw construct was 84% stiffer when compared with the four-screw construct (p = 0.0001). There was no significant change in flexion stiffness with addition of cross-links. In torsional testing the six-screw construct was 38% stiffer than the four-screw construct (p = 0.042).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
在腰椎融合术中,关于横向连接的有效性以及在拟融合节段的中间节段置入椎弓根螺钉的必要性仍存在争议。本研究的目的是评估用于三节段融合内固定的各种棒/螺钉结构的刚度,特别强调横向连接和中间椎弓根螺钉的作用。九个腰椎小牛脊柱标本固定于L1和L5水平。然后在L2、L3和L4双侧椎弓根置入椎弓根螺钉(TSRH,Danek公司,孟菲斯,田纳西州)。随后对以下结构进行随机序列测试:双侧连接L2和L4椎弓根的TSRH棒,有或无横向连接;以及双侧连接L2、L3和L4水平的棒,有或无横向连接。测试在改良的MTS试验机(MTS,明尼阿波利斯,明尼苏达州)上进行,包括轴向载荷、扭转以及屈伸的循环施加。测试得出轴向、矢状面和扭转刚度值。采用对数转换和Fisher最小显著差异检验进行统计分析。在轴向测试中,在中间椎弓根使用额外的螺钉使刚度平均增加160%(p = .007)。施加横向连接并未增加轴向加载时的刚度。在屈伸测试中,与四螺钉结构相比,六螺钉结构刚度高84%(p = 0.0001)。增加横向连接后屈伸刚度无显著变化。在扭转测试中,六螺钉结构比四螺钉结构刚度高38%(p = 0.042)。(摘要截断于250字)