Benedictow O J
Historisk institutt, Universitetet i Oslo.
Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen. 1994 Dec 10;114(30):3587-93.
In 1971, Abdel R. Omran, the epidemiologist, launched the concepts the epidemic transition and the demographic transition. Assuming that the epidemic and demographic structures of all preindustrial societies were similar, Omran attached these concepts to the epidemic and demographic transitions of the nineteenth century. He indicated that these were the only epidemic and demographic transitions in history. In this paper, it is argued that this assertion is untenable. Historically, there have been many societal transitions implying concurrent and interactive epidemic and demographic transitions. Two major historical events have been selected for illustrative purposes. The emergence of the western demographic system and the advent of plague in 1347 had dramatic impacts on epidemic and demographic conditions. Successful combat of plague, first in Italy, was organized with increasing efficiency from the second half of the fifteenth century on the basis of miasmatic-contagionist epidemiological notions. The antiepidemic organizations developed in this combat were efficient also against most other important epidemic diseases. The rise of antiepidemic organizations contributed to transitional change in epidemic and demographic structures with substantial impact on broader societal processes of modernization. These transitions preceded and conditioned the transitional processes referred to by Omran.
1971年,流行病学家阿卜杜勒·R·奥姆兰提出了“流行病学转变”和“人口转变”的概念。奥姆兰假定所有前工业化社会的流行病结构和人口结构相似,他将这些概念与19世纪的流行病学转变和人口转变联系起来。他指出,这些是历史上仅有的流行病学转变和人口转变。在本文中,可以论证这一断言是站不住脚的。从历史上看,有许多社会转型意味着同时发生且相互作用的流行病学转变和人口转变。为了说明问题,选取了两个重大历史事件。西方人口体系的出现以及1347年鼠疫的到来对流行病学状况和人口状况产生了巨大影响。首先在意大利,人们在15世纪下半叶基于瘴气—传染主义流行病学观念,越来越高效地组织起了对鼠疫的防治。在这场防治中发展起来的防疫组织对大多数其他重要流行病也很有效。防疫组织的兴起促成了流行病学结构和人口结构中的转型变化,对更广泛的现代化社会进程产生了重大影响。这些转变先于奥姆兰所提及的转型过程并对其起到了制约作用。