Bower C, Payne J, Condon R, Hendrie D, Harris A, Henderson R
Institute for Child Health Research, Perth, Australia.
J Paediatr Child Health. 1994 Oct;30(5):393-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1440-1754.1994.tb00686.x.
Between 1984 and 1990, 257 cases of Haemophilus influenzae type b (Hib) meningitis occurred in children under five years of age in Western Australia. We obtained information on possible sequelae in 131 cases (all non-Aboriginal) by medical record review and parental interview, and in a further 116 cases (60 non-Aboriginal, 56 Aboriginal) by medical record review only; no follow-up information was available for ten children (nine non-Aboriginal, 1 Aboriginal). The incidence of Hib meningitis in children under five years of age was 26.3 per 100,000 for non-Aboriginal and 152.2 per 100,000 for Aboriginal children. The case fatality rate was 3.5% for non-Aboriginal children and 14.0% for Aboriginal children. Sequelae were recorded for 17.1% of non-Aboriginal and 22.4% of Aboriginal children who survived Hib meningitis. Surviving Aboriginal children experienced severe sequelae following Hib meningitis almost three times more frequently than surviving non-Aboriginal children (10.5% vs 3.6%), although mild and moderate sequelae were not more common in Aboriginal children. The information on incidence and severity of sequelae in this study was obtained by chart review and parental interview, and hence may be subject to error or bias, particularly for mild and moderate disabilities. Outcomes like death and severe sequelae, such as cerebral palsy and profound intellectual and physical disability, are less subject to bias. Of Aboriginal children who contracted Hib meningitis in Western Australia over the study period, 22.8% either died or had severe sequelae, while only 7.0% of non-Aboriginal children experienced these severe outcomes.
1984年至1990年间,西澳大利亚州5岁以下儿童中发生了257例b型流感嗜血杆菌(Hib)脑膜炎病例。我们通过病历审查和家长访谈,获取了131例(均为非原住民)可能的后遗症信息;另外116例(60例非原住民、56例原住民)仅通过病历审查获取信息;10名儿童(9名非原住民、1名原住民)没有随访信息。5岁以下非原住民儿童Hib脑膜炎的发病率为每10万人26.3例,原住民儿童为每10万人152.2例。非原住民儿童的病死率为3.5%,原住民儿童为14.0%。在Hib脑膜炎中存活的非原住民儿童有17.1%出现后遗症,原住民儿童为22.4%。Hib脑膜炎后存活的原住民儿童出现严重后遗症的频率几乎是非原住民儿童的三倍(10.5%对3.6%),不过轻微和中度后遗症在原住民儿童中并不更常见。本研究中后遗症发病率和严重程度的信息通过图表审查和家长访谈获得,因此可能存在误差或偏差,尤其是对于轻微和中度残疾情况。死亡和严重后遗症,如脑瘫以及严重智力和身体残疾等结果,偏差较小。在研究期间于西澳大利亚州感染Hib脑膜炎的原住民儿童中,22.8%要么死亡要么有严重后遗症,而非原住民儿童只有7.0%出现这些严重后果。