Pellissier S, Duvoisin B, Fontolliet C, Monnier P
Service d'Oto-rhino-laryngologie, CHUV-BH10, Lausanne.
J Radiol. 1994 Nov;75(11):577-83.
The objective of this prospective study is to assess the impact of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and computed tomography (CT) as compared to physical examination in the choice of type of surgery for advanced intraoral cancers (with or without resection of the mandibula). From 1990 to 1993, we operated on 21 intraoral malignant tumors with segmental resection of the mandibula followed by a histological examination. The preoperative evaluation consisted of an MRI (n = 8), a CT (n = 8) or both (n = 5). MRI suspected an infiltration of the bone in 9 cases, CT in 4 and physical examination in 16. This was histologically confirmed in 6 of the 21 patients only. MRI and CT both have a high sensitivity, as does physical examination, but neither have a good specificity (physical examination: 5 true positive, 4 true negative, 11 false positive, 1 false negative; MRI: 4 true positive, 4 true negative, 5 false positive, 0 false negative; CT: 3 true positive, 7 true negative, 3 false positive, 0 false negative). In conclusion, the decision of a mandibular resection can only be taken after a careful physical examination, including palpation under general anesthesia in a fully relaxed patient. This is best accomplished during the pretherapy bronchoesophagoscopy, routinely performed for the detection of synchronous second primary tumors using toluidin blue as a vital staining method. If this initial evaluation gives a suspicion of a massive infiltration of the mandible, an MRI, rather than a CT, should be performed to determine the extent of the resection because of a high rate of artefacts with CT.
这项前瞻性研究的目的是评估磁共振成像(MRI)和计算机断层扫描(CT)与体格检查相比,在晚期口腔癌(无论是否切除下颌骨)手术类型选择中的影响。1990年至1993年,我们对21例口腔恶性肿瘤患者进行了下颌骨节段性切除并进行了组织学检查。术前评估包括MRI(n = 8)、CT(n = 8)或两者(n = 5)。MRI怀疑9例有骨浸润,CT怀疑4例,体格检查怀疑16例。21例患者中仅6例经组织学证实。MRI和CT以及体格检查均具有较高的敏感性,但特异性均不佳(体格检查:5例假阳性、4例假阴性、11例真阳性、例1真阴性;MRI:5例假阳性、4例假阴性、4例真阳性、0例真阴性;CT:3例假阳性、7例假阴性例、3例真阳性、0例真阴性)。总之,只有在仔细的体格检查后才能决定是否进行下颌骨切除,包括在全身麻醉下对完全放松的患者进行触诊。这最好在治疗前支气管食管镜检查期间完成,该检查常规用于使用甲苯胺蓝作为活体染色方法检测同步性第二原发性肿瘤。如果初步评估怀疑下颌骨有大量浸润,由于CT伪影发生率高,应进行MRI而非CT来确定切除范围。