Pfeiffer C, Wagner M L
Department of Pharmacy Practice, Rutgers, State University of New Jersey (RSUNJ), Piscataway 08855.
Am J Hosp Pharm. 1994 Dec 15;51(24):3047-53.
Recent research on the role of clozapine in the treatment of Parkinson's disease and other movement disorders is discussed. Most clinical trials have shown resolution of or improvement in psychotic symptoms accompanying Parkinson's disease without worsening of parkinsonian symptoms. Adverse effects appear to be mild at dosages of < 100 mg/day; sedation is the most frequent problem. Most of these studies have serious limitations, however; until better studies have been completed, the decision to use clozapine for Parkinson's disease-related psychosis should be made on a case-by-case basis, with thorough evaluation of risks, benefits, and other therapeutic options. Some patients with Parkinson's disease have shown improvement in tremor and other abnormal movements when given clozapine. Clozapine cannot be recommended for treating tardive dyskinesia on the basis of the research done so far; some trials show dramatic resolution of symptoms, others no benefit. Anticholinergics or dopamine-reuptake inhibitors should be considered before clozapine is given to patients with tardive dyskinesia because of clozapine's potential for serious adverse effects. A few patients with Huntington's disease have responded to clozapine, but again no conclusions can be drawn. Clozapine appears to offer no real advantage over haloperidol for treating choreiform movements in Huntington's disease. The frequency of tics in Tourette's syndrome does not seem to be reduced by clozapine. Clozapine has shown some efficacy as a treatment for psychosis and abnormal movements in Parkinson's disease. Results have been less promising for other movement disorders. Further study in larger populations is needed before any definitive conclusions about clozapine's place in movement disorder therapy can be made.
本文讨论了氯氮平在治疗帕金森病及其他运动障碍方面的最新研究。大多数临床试验表明,氯氮平可缓解或改善帕金森病伴发的精神症状,且不会加重帕金森症状。当剂量<100mg/天时,不良反应似乎较轻;镇静是最常见的问题。然而,这些研究大多存在严重局限性;在完成更好的研究之前,对于是否使用氯氮平治疗帕金森病相关精神病应逐案决定,并对风险、益处及其他治疗选择进行全面评估。一些帕金森病患者服用氯氮平后震颤及其他异常运动有所改善。基于目前的研究,不推荐使用氯氮平治疗迟发性运动障碍;一些试验显示症状显著缓解,另一些则无益处。由于氯氮平有产生严重不良反应的可能性,对于迟发性运动障碍患者,在给予氯氮平之前应考虑使用抗胆碱能药物或多巴胺再摄取抑制剂。少数亨廷顿病患者对氯氮平有反应,但同样无法得出结论。在治疗亨廷顿病的舞蹈样动作方面,氯氮平似乎并不比氟哌啶醇有真正优势。氯氮平似乎不能降低妥瑞氏综合征的抽动频率。氯氮平已显示出对帕金森病的精神病及异常运动有一定疗效。对于其他运动障碍,结果则不太乐观。在就氯氮平在运动障碍治疗中的地位得出任何明确结论之前,需要对更多人群进行进一步研究。