Dollahite J, Franklin D, McNew R
School of Human Environmental Sciences, University of Arkansas, Fayetteville 72701.
J Am Diet Assoc. 1995 Mar;95(3):341-4, 347; quiz 345-6. doi: 10.1016/s0002-8223(95)00087-9.
Forty-three menus that were to be used in a diet manual were designed to meet the requirements of a specific diet; provide 2,200 to 2,400 kcal, unless energy-restricted; meet the 1990 Dietary Guidelines for Americans; meet current recommendations for sodium (2g to 3 g/day), cholesterol (< or = 300 mg/day), and fiber (20g to 30 g/day); and meet or exceed the highest level for adults in the 1989 Recommended Dietary Allowances (RDAs). In addition, regular and low-fat, low-cholesterol menus for 1 week were collected from 11 hospitals throughout Arkansas. Menus were analyzed for energy, cholesterol, and 18 nutrients. Only 11% of the menus met the RDA for zinc. Half of the menus did not meet the RDA for vitamin B-6 and one third did not meet the RDA for iron. Zinc content of the menus was positively correlated (P < .001) with protein (r = .73) and with beef (r = .45). Vitamin B-6 was positively correlated with protein (r = .44, P < .001) and with all meat (r = .38, P < .01). Regular and low-fat, low-cholesterol hospital menus had the same nutrient inadequacies because they did not differ in total servings from any food group. These data indicate that the public may have difficulty choosing a diet that meets both the Dietary Guidelines and the RDAs.
用于饮食手册的43份菜单旨在满足特定饮食的要求;提供2200至2400千卡热量,除非有能量限制;符合1990年《美国膳食指南》;符合当前关于钠(2克至3克/天)、胆固醇(≤300毫克/天)和纤维(20克至30克/天)的建议;并达到或超过1989年《推荐膳食摄入量》(RDA)中成年人的最高水平。此外,还从阿肯色州的11家医院收集了为期1周的常规和低脂、低胆固醇菜单。对菜单进行了能量、胆固醇和18种营养素的分析。只有11%的菜单符合锌的RDA。一半的菜单不符合维生素B-6的RDA,三分之一的菜单不符合铁的RDA。菜单中的锌含量与蛋白质(r = 0.73)和牛肉(r = 0.45)呈正相关(P < 0.001)。维生素B-6与蛋白质(r = 0.44,P < 0.001)和所有肉类(r = 0.38,P < 0.01)呈正相关。常规和低脂、低胆固醇的医院菜单存在相同的营养素不足问题,因为它们在任何食物组的总份数上没有差异。这些数据表明,公众可能难以选择一种既符合膳食指南又符合RDA的饮食。