Netter P, Vogel W, Rammsayer T
Department of Psychology, University of Giessen, Germany.
Psychopharmacology (Berl). 1994 Jun;115(1-2):206-12. doi: 10.1007/BF02244773.
Individual differences in catecholamine response to stress and ethanol were tested in extraverts and introverts on the basis of Eysenck's drug postulate claiming that introverts would be less susceptible to sedative drugs like ethanol. Forty-four healthy males received either 0.8 g/kg ethanol mixed into a drink of caffeine-free cola or a respective placebo and were tested with a stressful mental arithmetic task before and 40 min after the intake of the drink. Plasma catecholamines were determined from blood samples drawn at five defined intervals from an indwelling cannula and self-ratings on deactivation, relaxation, and anxiety were obtained as well as quality and quantity of performance in the arithmetic task. Results showed that there was no difference in catecholamine stress responses between introverts (Ex -) and extraverts (Ex +) before the drink, but that the intake of the fluid (both ethanol and placebo) resulted in higher norepinephrine (NE) increases in Ex - than in Ex +. The combined effects of ethanol and stress yielded larger responses of longer durations in Ex - than in Ex +. The concomitant psychological changes showed larger reductions in anxiety and increases in relaxation as well as larger decrements in quality of performance (% errors) in introverts in spite of their higher catecholamine increases. Thus, the predictions on the basis of arousal theory could not be verified experimentally and the drug postulate has to be modified in the sense that introverts probably have a higher depletion of NE in the central nervous system under physical but not under mental stress which is reflected by higher levels in the plasma and respective decreases in performance and activation.
根据艾森克的药物假设,即内向者对乙醇等镇静药物的敏感性较低,对内向者和外向者在应对压力和乙醇时的儿茶酚胺反应的个体差异进行了测试。44名健康男性饮用了混入无咖啡因可乐中的0.8 g/kg乙醇或相应的安慰剂,并在饮用前和饮用后40分钟接受了一项紧张的算术任务测试。从留置套管在五个规定时间抽取的血样中测定血浆儿茶酚胺,并获得关于失活、放松和焦虑的自我评分,以及算术任务中的表现质量和数量。结果表明,在饮用饮料前,内向者(Ex -)和外向者(Ex +)之间的儿茶酚胺应激反应没有差异,但饮用液体(乙醇和安慰剂)后,内向者的去甲肾上腺素(NE)升高幅度高于外向者。乙醇和压力的联合作用在内向者中产生的反应比外向者更大,持续时间更长。尽管内向者的儿茶酚胺升高幅度更大,但伴随的心理变化显示,内向者的焦虑感降低、放松感增加以及表现质量(%错误率)下降幅度更大。因此,基于唤醒理论的预测无法通过实验得到验证,并且药物假设必须修改,即内向者在身体应激而非心理应激下,中枢神经系统中的NE可能消耗更高,这反映在血浆中更高的水平以及表现和激活的相应下降上。