Vos P G, van Dijk A, Schomaker L
Department of Psychology, University of Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
Perception. 1994;23(8):965-76. doi: 10.1068/p230965.
A method of time-series analysis and a time-beating experiment were used to test the structural and perceptual validity of notated metre. Autocorrelation applied to the flow of melodic intervals between notes from thirty fragments of compositions for solo instruments by J S Bach strongly supported the validity of bar length specifications. Time-beating data, obtained with four stimuli from the same set, played in an expressionless mode, and presented under categorically distinct tempos to different subgroups of musically trained subjects, were rather inconsistent with respect to tapped bar lengths. However, taps were most frequently given to the events in the stimuli that corresponded with the first beats according to the score notations. No significant effects of tempo on tapping patterns were observed. The findings are discussed in comparison with other examinations of metre inference from musical compositions.
采用时间序列分析方法和节拍实验来检验记谱节拍的结构和感知有效性。对约翰·塞巴斯蒂安·巴赫的三十首独奏乐器作品片段中音符间旋律音程的流动应用自相关分析,有力地支持了节拍长度规范的有效性。从同一组中选取四个刺激片段,以无表情的模式演奏,并以截然不同的速度呈现给不同分组的受过音乐训练的受试者,所获得的节拍数据在敲击节拍长度方面相当不一致。然而,根据乐谱记法,敲击最常出现在与第一拍相对应的刺激片段中的事件上。未观察到速度对敲击模式有显著影响。本文将这些研究结果与其他关于从音乐作品中推断节拍的研究进行了比较讨论。