Fosså S D, Droz J P, Stoter G, Kaye S B, Vermeylen K, Sylvester R
Department of Medical Oncology and Radiotherapy, Norwegian Radium Hospital, Oslo.
Br J Cancer. 1995 Mar;71(3):619-24. doi: 10.1038/bjc.1995.121.
The aims of the trial were to establish the response rate and determine the toxicity of combination chemotherapy with ifosphamide, vincristine and cisplatin (HOP regimen) in advanced metastatic seminoma and to study the role of post-chemotherapy consolidation treatment. Patients with bulky metastatic non-alpha-fetoprotein-producing seminomas were eligible for this phase II study [serum human chorionic gonadotropin < 200 U l-1 (< 40 ng l-1)] if they presented with abdominal masses > or = 10 cm or had extra-gonadal seminoma or had relapsed after previous radiotherapy. The HOP regimen consisted of four 3-weekly cycles of the following drug combination: ifosphamide (days 1-5, 1.2 mg m-2 day-1), vincristine (day 1, 2 mg) and cisplatin (days 1-5, 20 mg m-2 day-1). Residual masses persisting 6 months after chemotherapy could be considered for consolidation surgery or radiotherapy. Maximal response to the HOP chemotherapy (evaluated at any time) was based on the WHO criteria. The median observation time was 2.5 years (range 1.8-5.5 years). Thirteen institutions treated 42 eligible patients within the study (testicular cancer stage > or = IID, 25; extragonadal, 5; relapse after previous radiotherapy, 12). Two patients were not evaluable for response owing to premature treatment discontinuation. Maximal response was as follows: complete remission (CR), 26 (65%); partial remission (PR) 11 (28%); no change (NC), 2 (5%); progressive disease (PD), 1 (3%). Four patients have died, three from their malignancy (two without previous irradiation and one with prior radiotherapy). The fourth patient died of treatment-related toxicity. The 3 year survival for all 42 eligible patients was 90%. Dose reduction and treatment postponement were necessary in 25 and 14 patients respectively. Ten patients experienced granulocytic fever. Previously irradiated patients tolerated chemotherapy as well as non-irradiated patients. Immediately after HOP chemotherapy a mass persisted in 16 of 17 patients with retroperitoneal masses of > or = 100 mm at presentation. Three of these residual lesions were resected within the following 6 months showing complete necrosis. Four lesions dissolved spontaneously during the first year of follow-up. Nine lesions persisted for > or = 1 year (one after consolidation radiotherapy) without leading to relapse. Four of seven patients with mediastinal lesions achieved CR and three a PR after HOP chemotherapy. The HOP chemotherapy regimen is highly effective in patients with advanced metastatic seminoma or those relapsing after previous radiotherapy, but is associated with a high risk of toxicity, in particular myelotoxicity.
该试验的目的是确定晚期转移性精原细胞瘤患者接受异环磷酰胺、长春新碱和顺铂联合化疗(HOP方案)的缓解率并确定其毒性,同时研究化疗后巩固治疗的作用。如果患有大块转移性非甲胎蛋白生成性精原细胞瘤的患者出现腹部肿块≥10 cm,或患有性腺外精原细胞瘤,或在先前放疗后复发,则符合本II期研究的条件[血清人绒毛膜促性腺激素<200 U l-1(<40 ng l-1)]。HOP方案包括以下药物组合,每3周为1个周期,共4个周期:异环磷酰胺(第1 - 5天,1.2 mg m-2 天-1)、长春新碱(第1天,2 mg)和顺铂(第1 - 5天,20 mg m-2 天-1)。化疗后持续6个月的残留肿块可考虑进行巩固手术或放疗。对HOP化疗的最大反应(在任何时间评估)基于世界卫生组织标准。中位观察时间为2.5年(范围1.8 - 5.5年)。13个机构在该研究中治疗了42例符合条件的患者(睾丸癌分期≥IID期,25例;性腺外,5例;先前放疗后复发,12例)。2例患者因过早终止治疗而无法评估反应。最大反应如下:完全缓解(CR),26例(65%);部分缓解(PR),11例(28%);无变化(NC),2例(5%);疾病进展(PD),1例(3%)。4例患者死亡,3例死于恶性肿瘤(2例未接受过放疗,1例接受过放疗)。第4例患者死于治疗相关毒性。42例符合条件患者的3年生存率为90%。分别有25例和14例患者需要减少剂量和推迟治疗。10例患者出现粒细胞性发热。先前接受过放疗的患者与未接受放疗的患者对化疗的耐受性相同。HOP化疗后,17例初诊时腹膜后肿块≥100 mm的患者中有16例仍有肿块。其中3例残留病变在接下来的6个月内切除,显示完全坏死。4例病变在随访的第一年自发消退。9例病变持续≥1年(1例在巩固放疗后),未导致复发。7例纵隔病变患者中,4例在HOP化疗后达到CR,3例达到PR。HOP化疗方案对晚期转移性精原细胞瘤患者或先前放疗后复发的患者非常有效,但毒性风险高,尤其是骨髓毒性。